Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum

Full Version: Russian Ukraine Invasion
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
(Apr 29, 2022 08:07 PM)Zinjanthropos Wrote: [ -> ]Hey Yaz, with Ukraine hitting Russia near the border, has security in Moscow become extremely tight, are there curfews, is there real cause to worry if you live there? Guess that could also mean Government security coming down on citizens a lot more also.

I don't know, Z-man.

I've heard about police coming down hard to break up a few anti-war demonstrations in Moscow, but haven't heard about security checkpoints or anything like that. I don't believe that the city is in a war posture, with military defenses going up like we saw in Kyiv.

There aren't any street barricades and nobody is handing out military rifles to the public. Though I would speculate that air defenses are on a higher state of alert in case Ukraine tries a Jimmy Doolittle style air raid on the Russian defense ministry or something.
Quote:Mass Grave found in Mali
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/61257796
France has accused Russian mercenaries (Wagner) working in Mali of a smear campaign, involving dumping bodies at a mass grave found near an army base in Mali, recently used by French forces in order to blame the French.

Further Wagner involvments are mentioned:
https://www.dailysabah.com/world/africa/...yond-libya
https://medium.com/dfrlab/first-russian-...f9d5ac3abd

What it looks like to me is Russia has likely been taking conflict minerals (diamonds/gold etc) and washing them through their country. The instances where they've been portrayed heroes (like in Eritrea) were likely staged (such as leaking information to various people to create an attack which they then defend from, making sure they leave no witnesses to identify their involvement in the setup.)

I would go as far as to query if the global rise of "Woke" as something they've been heavily invested in manipulating. As being very public about racism, hatred and wrongdoing spans beyond the borders of the countries where it happens and poisons any chance of breaking the cycle of such hatred. This also opens the door for countries that aren't seen as the aggressors (Africa never had Russian imperialism push into it's territory historically, it doesn't however mean that isn't their plan now).

Generating a divide in Africa is also likely done to slight the UN political balance (desensitising countries to Russian acts), while attempting to vilify countries that are in the very slow process of reparation over their countries history.

It's a dangerous game where a bunch of white Zenophobe are attempting to dictate Africa's future... that should be up to Africans.
Day 66 Summary

https://militaryland.net/ukraine/invasio...6-summary/

More than two months in and Ukraine is winning as well as losing.

Several more small towns right outside Kharkiv have been retaken by the Ukrainians. Unlike the fiercely contested suburbs of Kyiv, the Russians don't seem to have fought very hard to keep these Kharkiv suburbs. There are videos of buses arriving to evacuate civilians from these towns. Houses appear intact without evidence of street fighting. The civilians look healthy and well fed after two months of Russian occupation, although they look eager to leave.

Further east, the Russians continue to advance very slowly south from Izium. Their objective may or may not be cutting the road running west from Slovyansk to Barvinkove, but their progress is almost imperceptible. Compare this with how the Russian forces surged all over the Ukrainian map very rapidly in the first days of the war.

Interestingly, there seems to have been more progress thrusting west from Izium. It isn't clear what their objective was in that direction and they seem to have attacked that way because there were few Ukrainian forces in that direction. Speculation is that these Russians intended to turn south after outflanking the Ukrainian defenders. Except that the Ukrainians rushed reinforcements to that sector and Russian progress here has ground to a near halt as well.

The Russians seem to have had their biggest success thrusting south from Terny through Zarichne towards Yampil. (A very small rural town.) This advance has so far bypassed the larger nearby town of Lyman (pop ~20K) which is being evacuated by Ukrainian police. Shelling is reported in Lyman. The intention with this thrust might be to sever the road between Slovyansk and Sierierodonetsk and maybe even encircle the Ukrainian forces holding out in the Sieverodonetsk and Lysychansk where urban street fighting appears to be occurring.

These are just about the only places in Ukraine where military forces are advancing or retreating. Lines are generally pretty static.

And (inevitably) Mariupol. Despite the Russians supposedly deciding to surround and starve the defenders out, Russian forces have continued to attack. Each of these attacks has been repelled. And Russian aircraft have been bombing the Azovstal steel plant heavily. This collapsed one of the tunnels where defenders were sheltering with unknown loss of life.

The united nations has reportedly negotiated some kind of safe passage for civilian women and children to leave the Azovstal tunnels, and 20 reportedly left today. Unclear how many there are, and the Russians aren't allowing males to leave.

In the west, there's shelling but little ground movement between Kherson (Russian occupied) and Mykolaiv (Ukrainian held). There have been some reports of Russian reinforcements in that area and speculation has been busy given the Transnistrian excitement, but it doesn't look like a Russian thrust westwards is in the cards. The biggest news seems to be continued Russian attempts to set up a separatist "republic" in Kherson oblast, despite overwhelming popular opposition to that idea. The Russians are insisting that like the Luhansk and Donetsk "republics", the new Kherson "republic" will never be returned to Ukrainian control.

[Image: 2022_Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine.svg]
Combat death puts spotlight on Americans fighting in Ukraine
www.politico.com/news/2022/05/01/marine-ukraine-killed-willy-cancel-00029197

INTRO: Harrison Jozefowicz quit his job as a Chicago police officer and headed overseas soon after Russia invaded Ukraine. An Army veteran, he said he couldn’t help but join American volunteers seeking to help Ukrainians in their fight.

Jozefowicz now heads a group called Task Force Yankee, which he said has placed more than 190 volunteers in combat slots and other roles while delivering nearly 15,000 first aid kits, helping relocate more than 80 families and helping deliver dozens of pallets of food and medical supplies to the southern and eastern fronts of the war.

It’s difficult, dangerous work. But Jozefowicz said he felt helpless watching from the United States last year during the U.S. pullout from Afghanistan, particularly after a close friend, Staff Sgt. Ryan Knauss, died in a suicide bombing at Kabul.

“So, I’m just trying to do everything I can to make sure I can help others not go through what I went through,” he said Saturday during an interview conducted through a messaging platform.

A former U.S. Marine who died last week was believed to be the first American citizen killed while fighting in Ukraine. Willy Joseph Cancel, 22, died Monday while working for a military contracting company that sent him to Ukraine, his mother, Rebecca Cabrera, told CNN.

An undetermined number of other Americans — many with military backgrounds — are thought to be in the country battling Russian forces beside both Ukrainians and volunteers from other countries even though U.S. forces aren’t directly involved in fighting aside from sending military materiel, humanitarian aid and money.

Russia’s invasion has given Ukraine’s embassy in Washington the task of fielding inquiries from thousands of Americans who want to help in the fight, and Ukraine is using the internet to recruit volunteers for a foreign force, the International Legion of Defense of Ukraine.

“Anyone who wants to join the defense of security in Europe and the world can come and stand side by side with the Ukrainians against the invaders of the 21st century,” President President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said in a recruitment pitch... (MORE - details)


Ukraine acknowledges that the ‘Ghost of Kyiv’ is a myth
www.nytimes.com/2022/05/01/world/europe/ghost-kyiv-ukraine-myth.html
- - - - - -

May 1, 2022 - Heroic ‘Ghost of Kyiv’ fighter doesn’t actually exist, Ukraine admits ... https://youtu.be/6KHFwYfT6CA
Reportedly, so many Canadian volunteers are fighting for Ukraine that a special Canadian-volunteer battalion group has been formed. (Canada has a huge Ukrainian immigrant community.)

Japanese volunteers

https://twitter.com/Militarylandnet/stat...3714417665

(Apr 29, 2022 08:07 PM)Zinjanthropos Wrote: [ -> ]Hey Yaz, with Ukraine hitting Russia near the border, has security in Moscow become extremely tight, are there curfews, is there real cause to worry if you live there? Guess that could also mean Government security coming down on citizens a lot more also.

Here's a fire in a large Moscow suburb called Mytishchi. It probably has nothing to do with Ukraine, but here it is.

https://twitter.com/igorsushko/status/15...5072265216
Civilians continue to be evacuated from Azovstal in an evacuation organized by the United Nations. It looks like the evacuees are being bussed to a tent camp where the Red Cross is much in evidence. Reports are that the first of these have arrived in Ukrainian controlled Zaporizhzhia.

Ukrainian video

https://twitter.com/Militarylandnet/stat...4719196160

Russian video

https://twitter.com/Militarylandnet/stat...6268814336



Very interesting news that the Ukrainians put a guided missile on top of the command post of the Russian 2'd Combined Arms Army in Izium. A spokesman from the Ukraine President's Office says that they believe that the strike killed Gen. Andrei Simonov, head of electronic warfare for the Russians' Western Military District, along with a number of lower ranking officers.

A "Senior US Defense Official" says the the Chief of the Russian General Staff Gen. Valery Gerasimov had been present at the command post earlier but had left before the Ukrainian missile hit.

The Americans believe that Gerasimov had been sent out from Moscow to evaluate the state of the Russian offensive (which has been making little progress). He was presumably trying to determine why the offensive has stalled on the Izium axis and whether it is worth while to shift resources to the Lyman salient to the east (which seems to be making better progress) or perhaps somewhere else.
Big news if true!!

https://nypost.com/2022/05/02/vladimir-p...fer-power/

Rumors are swirling that Vladimir Putin has cancer and is scheduled for surgery in coming days. He will reportedly turn over his powers temporarily to one of his most trusted allies, a former head of the FSB security police. The operation will reportedly only keep Putin out of action for a day or two. The nature and severity of the (supposed) cancer are unknown.

But it isn't clear that these rumors are even true. They are coming from alternative sources in Moscow. Pentagon spokesman John Kirby told reporters that he can't verify it.

People have noted that Putin hasn't looked well recently, but most have put it down to the stress of the war.

I should add that these kind of rumors are nothing new in Russia. There have been Putin-cancer rumors since at least 2014. So they need to be taken with a large grain of salt.
Javelin anti-tank missiles being shipped to Ukraine. A third of U.S. stockpiles. A real gamechanger in Ukraine's favor..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOckoCL65eA
(May 3, 2022 09:18 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: [ -> ]Javelin anti-tank missiles being shipped to Ukraine. A third of U.S. stockpiles. A real gamechanger in Ukraine's favor..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VOckoCL65eA

I'm kind of wondering what good tanks are anymore, other than becoming sitting ducks at some stage in a conflict. Lots of arguments are made after the pessimistic quote below as to why they are still relevant and necessary, and will remain even more so in the future. But I'm not sensing it in this invasion. 

I guess shooting shells from these mobile, big guns at a generous distance away is still cheaper than ordinary vehicles hauling stashes of small missiles and other explosive projectiles around to launch by hand-held equipment that's freer to scurry about (especially in tight spaces).

Do tanks still have a place in modern warfare?: Jack Watling, a research fellow at Royal United Services Institute says...

"There have been arguments made for some time that tanks are increasingly obsolete. The basis for this argument is that anti-tank guided missiles are now so effective that the level of protection needed to make a tank effective renders them too heavy to move operationally over relevant distances. Also as the vehicles become reliant on increasingly sophisticated systems the ability to repair them in the field decreases. Because of this increasing cost many nations are looking at reducing their tank fleets in favour of less protected missile carrying vehicles."
Day 70 Summary

https://www.understandingwar.org/backgro...ment-may-4

The biggest event today was multiple reports of the Russians successfully fighting their way into the Azovstal steel plant. (They've been trying for weeks but have been repelled each time.) Communications with the Ukrainian defenders has reportedly been lost, so nobody is sure what is happening in there. Presumably the Russians are trying to clear out the maze of tunnels under the plant where the Ukrainians, both regular soldiers, volunteer units and the surviving male civilians of the city of Mariupol (about 2,000 in total its believed) have been sheltering from almost constant bombing and shelling. (There are reportedly hundreds of wounded with little or no medical care available.) Hopefully what's happening will become clearer in a day or so. And hopefully the loss of life isn't too high. (I'm imagining those last Ukrainians fighting to the last man.)

I still think that this is one of those iconic battles that people will remember for generations, Ukraine's Stalingrad. It would make a good subject for a movie (and probably would at some point, if they still made war movies).

It appears that the Russians really want to fully control Mariupol by May 9, their Victory Day that comemorates the final surrender of Germany in World War II. The Russian commanders in Mariupol may have been ordered to make it happen no matter what the cost in Russian soldiers lives. Thousands of people are probably dying as I write this. Each Ukrainian will likely take at least one Russian with him.

First Deputy Head of the Russian Presidential Administration Sergey Kiriyenko has arrived in Mariupol and has apparently been appointed as some kind of Viceroy for the conquered bits of Ukraine. Reports are that surviving Mariupol civilians are being forced to clear main streets of rubble in exchange for food, in preparation for some big Russian Victory Day parade in which the liberation of the Russian occupied parts of Ukraine will be announced. Russian journalists are gathering in Mariupol to cover it. But it's expected that the war will continue after that and it won't mean the end of Russian offensive operations.

Other than that, Russia's grand offensive remains stalled.

Around Kharkiv (Ukraine's second largest city) Ukrainian forces reported no new advances today as they digest the suburbs and nearby villages they've retaken in recent days. The Russians responded by shelling the Kharkiv outskirts, as they've been doing since the start of the war. 

The attempt to stab south from Izium appears to have failed, despite the massing of tens of thousands of Russian troops there.

The Russians seem to be making better, if still very slow, progress near Lyman. They have taken Yampil and several other small villages. But they are still a long ways from encircling the Ukrainian army in the east which seems to have been their objective. American military observers increasingly think they can't do it.

The Ukrainians look to me to be wearing down in the area of Severodonetsk, but given the poor performance of the Russian army, they remain strong enough to prevent Russian advances. The Russians continue to tighten their grip on Rubizhne though, and appear to have surrounded some of the Ukrainian defenders in that small industrial city.

There hasn't been much movement in the Kherson-Mykolaiv front. Each side probes into rural areas and claims small villages and crossroads, but nothing of substance. The Ukrainians continue to worry about possible Russian movements towards Mykolaiv but it hasn't happened yet. It's possible that's the Russians' intention, to pin the Ukrainians down in the southwest.

And the Ukrainians are dismissing the Transnistrian threat. The Russians supposely had 1,500 troops there, but the Ukrainians think that it's closer to 300 combat capable soldiers, short on supplies. Ukrainian border guards are erecting concrete barriers on the roads between Ukraine and Transnistria.

A much more serious threat is the fact that Belarus has started big troop movements of its forces north of western Ukraine. It's unclear if the Belarussians have decided to enter the war (they say it's just maneuvers), but Ukraine says that it is ready for whatever they do. (Which raises the question whether NATO would be willing to enter far western Ukraine to fight Belarus even if it doesn't want to fight nuclear armed Russia. If that happened, Belarus would find its butt well and thoroughly kicked.)

And the Russians have redoubled their cruise missile attacks on western Ukraine. Targets seem to be railroads and electrical power infrastructure. Some western Ukrainian cities have reported blackouts. It's believed that the Russians are trying to disrupt increased flows of military and other aid from Europe and the US. Or maybe they are trying to soften up the area before the Belarussians go in.