(Dec 8, 2018 07:51 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: . . . The Sci-Fi Channel would make a miniseries of the novel in 2000...
Might be better to take another stab at that (as a multiple season series) using HBO standards rather than Syfy's. The complexities of a single 412-page book itself would receive better justice as a high-quality ten episodes (or even twenty if stretched over two years) rather than a restricted, three hour film. The
five sequels could carry it into either multiple seasons or increments. (Though admittedly, the unofficial HBO requirement that characters must utter at least one variation of the F-word _X_ number of times during a five minute period, regardless of the situation, could get adolescently monotonous for some viewers. Like listening to that neighbor who says "uh" or "you know" endlessly as a pause filler during routine conversations.)
Too bad Herbert is long dead. As George R. R. Martin stated below about the decisions for his own literary franchise -- if the first film flops, that's it for the rest.
Even when an opening work is a success as a film -- not to mention becoming a classic -- there's no guarantee of the others following. It's certainly not adult speculative fiction, but Frank Baum did write circa 14 Oz books. But
largely it was vastly inferior, faux attempts at sequels over the decades that followed (cartoons some), which weren't part of the original canon. (For a good while it was literally as if the industry was completely ignorant of Baum having written more installments.)
Why George R R Martin said no to a "Game of Thrones" movie for 15 years:
George R. R. Martin has discussed why he held out for a Game of Thrones TV series for over a decade, saying he didn't want his novels to go the same way in adaptation as Tolkein's "Lord of the Rings".
In spite of sacks of cash being thrown at him, the author was simply not willing to compromise his books by having huge sections of them removed to fit a film narrative. "It took Peter Jackson three movies to make Tolkien's Lord of the Rings, and he still had to cut things," Martin told Melvyn Bragg during an interview for The South Bank Show.
"It would take three movies for *A Storm of Swords* alone! And if you figure like two movies for *A Game of Thrones*, and two for *A Clash of Kings*, you're already up to seven movies and you're halfway through the series. Nobody's going to commit to that, and, of course, they didn't commit to that."
Martin refused to cave to pressure, and did not want to see his series manipulated into a Jon Snow hero story with a few supporting characters. [...] "I didn't need the money so I had the power to say the sexiest word in Hollywood – 'No'."
[...] George went on to say that filmmakers suggested to him that if the first film was a hit then sequels would follow. However, the writer cited Philip Pullman's wildly successful *His Dark Materials* book series, which only saw one movie being made and any potential followups shelved due to its lack of success at the box office.
It appears that the writer made the right choice by opting for a TV adaptation and foregoing Hollywood...
https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/enter...92677.html
https://www.express.co.uk/showbiz/tv-rad...Winter-HBO
~