Aug 24, 2025 09:04 PM
12/17/2024
Ireland’s ICJ bid to redefine genocide amid the war in Gaza isn’t impossible but suggests that the Irish government knows the accusations against Israel can’t hold their ground
Ireland is going to request that the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in the Hague broaden its interpretation of genocide amid the ongoing war between Israel and Hamas, with Ireland’s deputy prime minister, Micheál Martin, asserting that the IDF’s actions in Gaza constitute “collective punishment” of Palestinians.
...
Dr. Tammy Caner, director of the Law and National Security Program at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), believes it is essential to seek explanations from Israel “regarding its controversial military actions; Israel may not be perfect and has made several mistakes, but the only genocidal war criminal in this war is Hamas. Requesting the ICJ to broaden its interpretation explicitly indicates that Israel is not committing genocide.”
Lieblich also agrees that attempting to change the definition of genocide amid a trial on the subject tells how the case is being seen by its supporters. “The text of the letter is a double-edged sword for the case since Ireland seems to concede that the accepted interpretation of the crime would not apply in this case and argues that it should be changed,” he argued.
