Justified deportation: Why Starmer’s ECHR reset will fail? (British brewing)

#1
C C Offline
RELATED (scivillage): 170 'dangerous' foreign nationals cannot be deported ... Starmer admits 'no effective deterrent in the Channel' to stop migrants ... UK looking at Denmark model to cut illegal migration ... Mahmood to announce ‘sweeping reforms’ to tackle illegal migration
- - - - - - - - -

PREFACE: Keir Starmer is seeking changes to how the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) works. Unfortunately, given the underlying principles of the ECHR, it is unlikely that this attempt will succeed.

JACOB REES-MOGG
https://youtu.be/kAGlO0WP56U

VIDEO EXCERPTS: It is absolutely fascinating that the European Convention on Human Rights -- when it was first signed in 1950 -- includes no mention of democracy or elections. That comes in a protocol in 1952.

And this is a reminder that the European Convention on Human Rights is not a document rooted in democracy but rooted in super national power and in treaty obligations. It is not about democracy. It is not about the people. It is about the elite. In the current jargon, Davos man, not that Davos man existed in 1950.

It's interesting as a preamble to what's been happening in relation to the government's discussions to change the interpretation of the treaty and the way it's applied and the relationship between the court and member states.

What are they [Starmer administration] asking for? Well, they're asking for a number of things. They're asking for it to be easier to deport foreign criminals, that the concerns about inhuman and degrading treatment should be reasonable and proportionate, that it should be possible to send people to safe third countries...

[...] So they're looking to create more flexibility that member states have to pull at the edges on the rulings of ECHR. It's actually something that was thought to be very limited when we joined -- brought the ECHR into British law in the human rights act.

Now the question is will this have any chance of working? What will it actually do? [...] This isn't going to happen tomorrow. The European Court of Human Rights is not going to say tomorrow that you can send people to Rwanda or that you can send dangerous criminals back home because their right to family life has been lessened or that the difficulty they'll face in their home country is minor.

And we've had all sorts of things. You will know about the McNuggets case because I've discussed that on GB News. The trivial things that were deemed to be unreasonable to send people back to face, those won't change overnight, even if they ever do change.

But actually, there's a fundamental problem with the European Convention and the European Court. And that goes back to my first point. [...] the convention is not rooted in democracy.

[...] What happens in Europe with the European Convention on Human Rights is that an initial document was agreed in 1950 and 1952 and now all the member states can do is write letters saying will you think about this? They can't change the law. They can't vote to alter the law.

[...] And this seems to me a fundamental problem and a fundamental illegitimacy of the whole concept of European Human Rights. There's nothing wrong with it as a worthy objective, as a statement of aims, of things that you hope countries will do. But any legal system, anything that affects the daily life of us as citizens of the United Kingdom or of the government ought to be changeable.

[...] And that's why we should leave. We shouldn't leave just because I don't like some of the judgments. I wouldn't suggest that ... Voters can demand something different. But that's just not true with the European Convention. There is no means of enforcing change.

[...] that's why human rights as a concept do not work because they undermine the fundamental human right of democracy. And go back to my starting point. This convention is not grounded in democracy. It is grounded in super nationalism. An invalid super nationalism that has no basis and cannot be changed...

Starmer’s ECHR reset will fail ... https://youtu.be/kAGlO0WP56U

https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/kAGlO0WP56U
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Why do East Europeans dislike LGBT+ while the West adores? (continental brewing) C C 4 623 Oct 7, 2026 05:08 PM
Last Post: C C
  Article Green Party leaps ahead of Labour - scary left coalition looms? (British brewing) C C 0 486 Mar 4, 2026 02:22 AM
Last Post: C C
  UK hasn't been colonised? Why campaigning in a foreign language? (British brewing) C C 0 476 Feb 26, 2026 01:24 AM
Last Post: C C
  Article Europe now judged on military credibility - UK is falling short (British brewing) C C 1 466 Feb 13, 2026 01:29 AM
Last Post: Syne
  Article London refuses solo move on Russian assets, backs off without EU (British brewing) C C 3 715 Dec 22, 2025 09:28 PM
Last Post: Syne
  Article Starmer admits 'no effective deterrent in the Channel' to stop migrants (UK brewing) C C 0 426 Nov 29, 2025 02:14 AM
Last Post: C C
  Article Just how worried you should be about Russian ships off UK waters? (British brewing) C C 0 451 Nov 24, 2025 08:22 PM
Last Post: C C
  Article BBC controversy shows how precarious UK sovereignty has become (British brewing) C C 10 1,918 Nov 18, 2025 07:07 PM
Last Post: C C
  Article Israel’s embrace of Tommy Robinson deepens rift with British Jewry (UK brewing) C C 6 1,573 Nov 5, 2025 06:34 AM
Last Post: Syne
  Article Sharia law isn’t taking over – it’s just colonial legacy continuing (British brewing) C C 2 797 Oct 31, 2025 01:53 AM
Last Post: C C



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)