Jews that are anti-Israel: An ideology that goes back a century (DIY persistence)

[C C]

Though the video's topic concerns paid protesters, what's actually interesting here is the interview at the start with the Jewish woman who is an anti-Zionist. This woman claims that she even helped found the DSA back in the early 1980s. Her political community is a kind of throwback to all the NYC and Chicago communist party Jews in the first half of the 20th-century, who were likewise anti-Zionists. Marxism came first for these folk, not their ethnic ties.

In the spoiler below, you can see how the rhetoric (for these socialist Jews) has not changed since that era. It was simply revived after the original loyalty to the Soviet Union evaporated in the 1960s from the disillusionment that followed certain revelations. In the late 1940s, it was actually the USSR that got the anti-Zionist Jews in America to flip-flop (temporarily) in their hostile stance toward Israel.

The Forgotten History of the Jewish, Anti-Zionist Left
https://inthesetimes.com/article/jewish-...-apartheid

EXCERPTS: But for the Jewish left — the communist, socialist, Trotskyist and Marxist left — their critique of Zionism came from two quarters: a critique of nationalism and a critique of colonialism. They understood Zionism as a right-wing nationalism and, in that sense, bourgeois.

They saw it as in line with other forms of nationalism — an attempt to align the working class with the interests of the bourgeoisie. There was at the time a well-known takedown of Vladimir Jabotinsky in the New Masses in 1935, in which Marxist critic Robert Gessner calls Jabotinsky a little Hitler on the Red Sea. Gessner calls the Zionists Nazis and the left in general saw Jewish nationalism as a right-wing formation trying to create a unified, militaristic culture that aligns working-class Jewish interests with the interests of the Jewish bourgeoisie [the capitalist enemy].

So that’s one critique of Zionism. The other critique of Zionism, which I think is more contemporary to the left today, is that Zionism is a form of imperialism. If you look at the pamphlets and magazines and speeches that are given on the Jewish left in the 1930s and ​’40s, they saw that Zionists were aligning themselves with British imperialism.

They also were very aware of the fact that the Middle East was colonized, first by the Ottomans and then by the British. They saw the Palestinian struggle for liberation as part of a global anti-imperialist movement.

Of course, Jewish communists saw themselves not as citizens of a nation-state, but as part of the global proletariat: part of the global working class, part of the global revolution. And so for them to think about their homeland as this small strip of land in the Mediterranean — regardless of any cultural affinity to Jerusalem — would just be against everything they believe.

[...] Ironically, perhaps, the Soviet Union did more than any other single force to change the minds of the Jewish Marxist left in the late 1940s about Israel. Andrei Gromyko, the Soviet Union’s ambassador to the United Nations, came out in 1947 and backed partition in the United Nations after declaring the Western world did nothing to stop the Holocaust, and suddenly there’s this about-face. All these Jewish left-wing publications that were denouncing Zionism, literally the next day, were embracing partition and the formation of the nation-state of Israel.

You have to understand, for a lot of Jewish communists and even socialists, the Soviet Union was the promised land — not Zionism...

I exposed more paid protestors *got attacked* ... https://youtu.be/BrzcbKjWhOc

https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/BrzcbKjWhOc

[Syne]

Leftists have never changed. No matter how they talk about helping minorities, politics is always the primary motive, even for the minorities themselves.

Wow, this woman doesn't think Israel is a diverse state, even though Jews, Christians, Muslims, and Armenians all live together there.