Thirty Years On, How Well Do Global Warming Predictions Stand Up?


Mr. Hansen’s testimony described three possible scenarios for the future of carbon dioxide emissions. He called Scenario A “business as usual,” as it maintained the accelerating emissions growth typical of the 1970s and ’80s. This scenario predicted the earth would warm 1 degree Celsius by 2018. Scenario B set emissions lower, rising at the same rate today as in 1988. Mr. Hansen called this outcome the “most plausible,” and predicted it would lead to about 0.7 degree of warming by this year. He added a final projection, Scenario C, which he deemed highly unlikely: constant emissions beginning in 2000. In that forecast, temperatures would rise a few tenths of a degree before flatlining after 2000.

Thirty years of data have been collected since Mr. Hansen outlined his scenarios—enough to determine which was closest to reality. And the winner is Scenario C. Global surface temperature has not increased significantly since 2000, discounting the larger-than-usual El Niño of 2015-16. Assessed by Mr. Hansen’s model, surface temperatures are behaving as if we had capped 18 years ago the carbon-dioxide emissions responsible for the enhanced greenhouse effect. But we didn’t. And it isn’t just Mr. Hansen who got it wrong. Models devised by the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change have, on average, predicted about twice as much warming as has been observed since global satellite temperature monitoring began 40 years ago.

What about Mr. Hansen’s other claims? Outside the warming models, his only explicit claim in the testimony was that the late ’80s and ’90s would see “greater than average warming in the southeast U.S. and the Midwest.” No such spike has been measured in these regions.
Several more of Mr. Hansen’s predictions can now be judged by history. Have hurricanes gotten stronger, as Mr. Hansen predicted in a 2016 study? No. Satellite data from 1970 onward shows no evidence of this in relation to global surface temperature. Have storms caused increasing amounts of damage in the U.S.? Data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration show no such increase in damage, measured as a percentage of gross domestic product. How about stronger tornadoes? The opposite may be true, as NOAA data offers some evidence of a decline. The list of what didn’t happen is long and tedious.
The problem with Mr. Hansen’s models—and the U.N.’s—is that they don’t consider more-precise measures of how aerosol emissions counter warming caused by greenhouse gases. Several newer climate models account for this trend and routinely project about half the warming predicted by U.N. models, placing their numbers much closer to observed temperatures. The most recent of these was published in April by Nic Lewis and Judith Curry in the Journal of Climate, a reliably mainstream journal.

These corrected climate predictions raise a crucial question: Why should people world-wide pay drastic costs to cut emissions when the global temperature is acting as if those cuts have already been made?

So if you trusted the science 30 years ago, would you trust it again? Seems like a familiar refrain, how many times have I done so.....trusting the science. I've flip flop more than an iHop pancake over the years, always going with the science. Is it because it's usually wrong or because I understand knowledge grows each passing day? Wink
The problem isn't that science advances. The problem is that people get dogmatic about the old science and refuse to view new data and models.
(Jul 26, 2018 10:39 PM)Syne Wrote: The problem isn't that science advances. The problem is that people get dogmatic about the old science and refuse to view new data and models.

You said it better than I did.

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Oceans not warming faster Syne 10 392 Nov 17, 2018 08:23 PM
Last Post: confused2
  Global Warming My Ass! Yazata 3 357 Nov 19, 2016 10:20 PM
Last Post: RainbowUnicorn
  'Super Corals' Could Survive Warming Oceans C C 0 328 Nov 30, 2015 09:00 PM
Last Post: C C
  Scientists Ask Obama (etc) To Prosecute Global Warming Skeptics C C 3 620 Sep 20, 2015 06:54 PM
Last Post: elte
  Study highlights ways to boost weather, climate predictions C C 0 443 May 20, 2015 06:00 PM
Last Post: C C

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)