Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Against accommodationism: How science undermines religion

#1
C C Offline
http://blog.talkingphilosophy.com/?p=9169

EXCERPT: There is currently a fashion for religion/science accommodationism, the idea that there’s room for religious faith within a scientifically informed understanding of the world. Accommodationism of this kind gains endorsement even from official science organizations such as, in the United States, the National Academy of Sciences and the American Association for the Advancement of Science. But how well does it withstand scrutiny? Not too well, according to a new book by distinguished biologist Jerry A. Coyne....
Reply
#2
elte Offline
(Jan 6, 2016 04:47 AM)C C Wrote: http://blog.talkingphilosophy.com/?p=9169

EXCERPT: There is currently a fashion for religion/science accommodationism, the idea that there’s room for religious faith within a scientifically informed understanding of the world. Accommodationism of this kind gains endorsement even from official science organizations such as, in the United States, the National Academy of Sciences and the American Association for the Advancement of Science. But how well does it withstand scrutiny? Not too well, according to a new book by distinguished biologist Jerry A. Coyne....

It could be that there was a benevolent deity that had a part in reality once upon a time.  But evidence for such a being existing now is lacking.
Reply
#3
Yazata Offline
(Jan 6, 2016 04:47 AM)C C Wrote: There is currently a fashion for religion/science accommodationism, the idea that there’s room for religious faith within a scientifically informed understanding of the world.

The idea that religion is primarily a matter of faith is a peculiarly Christian understanding of what religion is. (Most religions are more concerned with practice than with the content of belief.)

It's interesting (and a little sad) that atheists so often seem to think of 'religion' in thoroughly Christian terms. Atheists (even those who call themselves 'secular Jews') are often just as embedded in an evangelical Protestant paradigm as those they despise, except that they react violently against it.

Regarding 'accomodationism', anyone even halfway familiar with the history of science should know that historically, most scientists have possessed some kind of personal religious sensibility. That was as true for Einstein and Schroedinger as it was for Newton and Kepler.

Quote:Accommodationism of this kind gains endorsement even from official science organizations such as, in the United States, the National Academy of Sciences and the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

What's the alternative supposed to be? Scientists espousing militant atheism and writing poorly-informed popular atheism titles isn't going to make religion go away. And religious hostility towards particular scientific ideas isn't going to make those ideas go away.

Given that fact, given the fact that most scientists possess some religiosity, and given that most religious people value and respect science, everyone probably should strive for peaceful coexistence.

I don't think that's impossible at all, as long as religious people avoid scriptural literalism on scientific matters such as creation and the origin of biological 'kinds', and scientists avoid grasping too tightly to metaphysical naturalism and stop promoting doctrines like the so-called 'conflict thesis' (science and religion in a historical/cultural death-struggle) which don't appear to be supported by the historical evidence.

Quote:But how well does it withstand scrutiny? Not too well, according to a new book....

Some of the less interesting 'new' atheists seem to have concluded that religion is bullshit and there's no reason for them to waste valuable time getting formal education in bullshit. (They already have PhDs and prestige teaching appointments, so why bother?) Unfortunately, that's a recipe for ignorance, shallow thinking and noisy but unconvincing rhetoric.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article Orthodox Science as a (mostly good) religion C C 2 68 Mar 14, 2024 05:59 PM
Last Post: confused2
  What science can learn from religion? C C 8 424 Sep 17, 2021 09:06 PM
Last Post: Syne
  Science should not try to absorb religion and other ways of knowing C C 1 119 Jun 26, 2021 12:48 AM
Last Post: Syne
  "The science-versus-religion opposition is a barrier to thought" C C 0 332 Dec 1, 2019 01:50 AM
Last Post: C C
  The conflict between science and religion lies in our brains C C 1 412 Aug 15, 2018 05:33 PM
Last Post: Ostronomos
  War between religion & science: From conflict to dialogue & all the way back C C 3 596 Jan 7, 2018 01:12 AM
Last Post: Yazata
  Does religion protect against suicide? + Myth-making & disability in Africa C C 13 1,333 Sep 22, 2017 02:16 AM
Last Post: Syne
  SEP: Religion and Science C C 1 545 Jan 24, 2017 04:31 AM
Last Post: Zinjanthropos
  Ted Cruz: ‘Climate Change Is Not Science. It’s Religion.’ C C 2 952 Jul 2, 2016 07:33 PM
Last Post: Yazata
  Why Science Is Not in Conflict with Religion C C 3 694 Jun 27, 2016 02:47 AM
Last Post: Secular Sanity



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)