Game Day: Sam Harris versus Noam Chomsky

[C C]

The limits of discourse
http://www.samharris.org/blog/item/the-l...-discourse

EXCERPT: Sam Harris asked Noam Chomsky to engage in a public dialogue about war, terrorism, and surveillance. Their exchange didn’t go well....

[Magical Realist]

Reminds me of two old dogs growling at each other on the sidewalk. What a waste of their intellects. Maybe debates ARE better held face to face. If at all. To me debating artificially reduces thought to a matter of mere position-taking. As if a mind can be held to a set of truth propositions separate from itself.

[Yazata]

I'm with Sam Harris on this one.

I can't stand Noam Chomsky. He did some very good work in the philosophy of language decades ago, but has turned himself into a caricature of the left-wing intellectual since.