Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 4 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Religion has no monopoly on transcendent experience

#1
C C Offline
https://aeon.co/essays/religion-has-no-m...experience


EXCERPT: [...] What does one call such an experience? Pullman refers to it as ‘transcendent’. The philosopher and psychologist William James called them ‘religious experiences’ – although Pullman, who wrote a fictionalised biography of Jesus, would insist that God was not involved. Other psychologists call such moments spiritual, mystical, anomalous or out-of-the-ordinary. My preferred term is ‘ecstatic’. Today, we think of ecstasy as meaning the drug MDMA or the state of being ‘very happy’, but originally it meant ekstasis – a moment when you stand outside your ordinary self, and feel a connection to something bigger than you. Such moments can be euphoric, but also terrifying.

Over the past five centuries, Western culture has gradually marginalised and pathologised ecstasy. That’s partly a result of our shift from a supernatural or animist worldview to a disenchanted and materialist one. In most cultures, ecstasy is a connection to the spirit world. In our culture, since the 17th century, if you suggest you’re connected to the spirit world, you’re likely to be considered ignorant, eccentric or unwell. Ecstasy has been labelled as various mental disorders: enthusiasm, hysteria, psychosis. It’s been condemned as a threat to secular government. We’ve become a more controlled, regulated and disciplinarian society, in which one’s standing as a good citizen relies on one’s ability to control one’s emotions, be polite, and do one’s job. The autonomous self has become our highest ideal, and the idea of surrendering the self is seen as dangerous.

Yet ecstatic experiences are surprisingly common, we just don’t talk about them. The polling company Gallup has, since the 1960s, measured the frequency of mystical experiences in the United States. In 1960, only 20 per cent of the population said they’d had one or more. Now, it’s around 50 per cent. In a survey I did in 2016, 84 per cent of respondents said they’d had an experience where they went beyond their ordinary self, and felt connected to something greater than them. But 75 per cent agreed there was a taboo around such experiences.

[...] For most people, contemplation is a way to take a break from the chattering ego-mind. But occasionally people have more powerful experiences of ego-dissolution, especially on retreats. [...] Psychologists and psychiatrists are moving from their traditional hostility to ecstasy to an understanding that it’s often good for us. [...] Yet there are risks to ego-dissolution too....

MORE: https://aeon.co/essays/religion-has-no-m...experience
Reply
#2
Magical Realist Offline
Good article. Welcome back CC!

"The journey beyond the self is not safe or predictable. On the other hand, staying in the self also has its risks – boredom, staleness, sterility, despair. Ultimately, there’s something in us that calls to us, that pulls us out the door. Let’s find out where it leads."
Reply
#3
Magical Realist Offline
I've had a couple of those panontic mystical moments in my own life. My encounter with the Grand Canyon was one. Being on the cusp of a summer thunderstorm. Looking out over the Atlantic from my ship at the gigantic mountain of the Azores looming over the horizon. One is humbled and dazed by such vastness. A sense of presence to some force or reality hugely beyond your own life going on indifferently to you. A universe that could smash you like a bug if it had a mind to but that somehow enters your flickering microscopic experience.
Reply
#4
Syne Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 07:30 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: I've had a couple of those panontic mystical moments in my own life. My encounter with the Grand Canyon was one. Being on the cusp of a summer thunderstorm. Looking out over the Atlantic from my ship at the gigantic mountain of the Azores looming over the horizon. One is humbled and dazed by such vastness. A sense of presence to some force or reality hugely beyond your own life going on indifferently to you. A universe that could smash you like a bug if it had a mind to but that somehow enters your flickering microscopic experience.

None of that sound anything like a transcendent religious experience. Rolleyes

Transcendent experiences are life-affirming, not life-negating.
Reply
#5
Magical Realist Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 08:42 PM)Syne Wrote: [quote='Magical Realist' pid='12366' dateline='1499193032']
I've had a couple of those panontic mystical moments in my own life. My encounter with the Grand Canyon was one. Being on the cusp of a summer thunderstorm. Looking out over the Atlantic from my ship at the gigantic mountain of the Azores looming over the horizon. One is humbled and dazed by such vastness. A sense of presence to some force or reality hugely beyond your own life going on indifferently to you. A universe that could smash you like a bug if it had a mind to but that somehow enters your flickering microscopic experience.


None of that sound anything like a transcendent religious experience.  Rolleyes



Transcendent experiences are life-affirming, not life-negating.

Transcendent experiences are reality affirming, not self affirming. Otherwise getting promoted in your career would be considered a transcendent experience.
Reply
#6
Syne Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 08:55 PM)Magical Realist Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 08:42 PM)Syne Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 07:30 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: I've had a couple of those panontic mystical moments in my own life. My encounter with the Grand Canyon was one. Being on the cusp of a summer thunderstorm. Looking out over the Atlantic from my ship at the gigantic mountain of the Azores looming over the horizon. One is humbled and dazed by such vastness. A sense of presence to some force or reality hugely beyond your own life going on indifferently to you. A universe that could smash you like a bug if it had a mind to but that somehow enters your flickering microscopic experience.


None of that sound anything like a transcendent religious experience.  Rolleyes



Transcendent experiences are life-affirming, not life-negating.

Transcendent experiences are reality affirming, not self affirming. Otherwise getting promoted in your career would be considered a transcendent experience.
No, you silly bugger, transcendent literally means "surpassing the ordinary; exceptional". Reality is, by definition, ordinary. Experiencing something beyond ordinary is life-affirming.

But I don't expect you to have any basis to compare the religiously transcendent.
Reply
#7
Magical Realist Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 09:14 PM)Syne Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 08:55 PM)Magical Realist Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 08:42 PM)Syne Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 07:30 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: I've had a couple of those panontic mystical moments in my own life. My encounter with the Grand Canyon was one. Being on the cusp of a summer thunderstorm. Looking out over the Atlantic from my ship at the gigantic mountain of the Azores looming over the horizon. One is humbled and dazed by such vastness. A sense of presence to some force or reality hugely beyond your own life going on indifferently to you. A universe that could smash you like a bug if it had a mind to but that somehow enters your flickering microscopic experience.


None of that sound anything like a transcendent religious experience.  Rolleyes



Transcendent experiences are life-affirming, not life-negating.

Transcendent experiences are reality affirming, not self affirming. Otherwise getting promoted in your career would be considered a transcendent experience.
No, you silly bugger, transcendent literally means "surpassing the ordinary; exceptional". Reality is, by definition, ordinary. Experiencing something beyond ordinary is life-affirming.

But I don't expect you to have any basis to compare the religiously transcendent.

LOL! You're the last person I'm going to accept any advice on spirituality from. You wouldn't know transcendent if it slapped you in the face.
Reply
#8
Syne Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 09:31 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: LOL! You're the last person I'm going to accept any advice on spirituality from. You wouldn't know transcendent if it slapped you in the face.

Says the atheist. Rolleyes
Reply
#9
Magical Realist Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 09:35 PM)Syne Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 09:31 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: LOL! You're the last person I'm going to accept any advice on spirituality from. You wouldn't know transcendent if it slapped you in the face.

Says the atheist.  Rolleyes


See? You have no concept of how spirituality can exist separately from theism. That's how stunted you are.
Reply
#10
Syne Offline
(Jul 4, 2017 09:39 PM)Magical Realist Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 09:35 PM)Syne Wrote:
(Jul 4, 2017 09:31 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: LOL! You're the last person I'm going to accept any advice on spirituality from. You wouldn't know transcendent if it slapped you in the face.

Says the atheist.  Rolleyes


See? You have no concept of how spirituality can exist separately from theism. That's how stunted you are.

I'm not sure you even understand the word, considering your "spiritually transcendent" experience....that makes you feel insignificant. Sounds more like nihilism. Rolleyes
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article This is what a near-death experience actually feels like C C 1 101 Feb 20, 2024 04:44 AM
Last Post: Magical Realist
  Sports as a spiritual experience Magical Realist 2 112 Sep 10, 2023 08:15 PM
Last Post: Magical Realist
  Self-transcendent experiences Magical Realist 2 106 May 25, 2023 06:40 PM
Last Post: Magical Realist
  Philosopher A J Ayer's near death experience Magical Realist 4 145 Nov 19, 2021 06:23 AM
Last Post: C C
  Miracles: people who feel their lives are threatened more likely to experience them C C 0 108 Aug 19, 2020 02:45 AM
Last Post: C C
  The 9 characteristics of mystical experience Magical Realist 1 243 Dec 18, 2019 05:40 AM
Last Post: C C
  Guns and Zombies: Gimme that end-time religion, Gimme that end-time religion C C 2 848 Oct 28, 2015 09:04 PM
Last Post: C C



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)