Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Is the biological model of mental illness inhumane?

#1
Magical Realist Online
It doesn't bother me thinking that I have a brain defect that symptomizes itself as my depression, anxiety, and anti-sociality. If anything it means its not my fault. It isn't a character flaw or a personality defect that I should be ashamed of. As Rumi said: "Your wound is where the light enters"..We form our personality and unique self around the axis of our own brain functions, however skewed it might be. It is the genetic cards we were dealt at birth. And so we play the game with that less than perfect hand, however much this questions our assumptions of being normal and free human beings.
==========================================================
"A common critical refrain in mental health is that explaining mental health problems in terms of a ‘brain disorder’ strips meaning from the experience, humanity from the individual, and is potentially demeaning.

But this only holds true if you actually believe that having a brain disorder is somehow dehumanising and this constant attempt to distance people with ‘mental health problems’ from those with ‘brain disorders’ reveals an implicit and disquieting prejudice.

It’s perhaps worth noting that there are soft and hard versions of this argument.

The soft version just highlights a correlation and says that neurobiological explanations of mental health problems are associated with seeing people in less humane ways. In fact, there is good evidence for this in that biomedical explanations of mental health problems have been reliably associated with slightly to moderately more stigmatising attitudes.

This doesn’t imply that neurobiological explanations are necessarily wrong, nor suggests that they should be avoided, because fighting stigma, regardless of the source, is central to mental health. This just means we have work to do.

This work is necessary because all experience, thought and behaviour must involve the biology of the body and brain, and mental health problems are no different. Contrary to how it is sometimes portrayed, this approach doesn’t exclude social, interpersonal, life history or behavioural explanations. In fact, we can think of every type of explanation as a tool for understanding ourselves, rather than a mutually exclusive explanation of which only one must be true.

On the other hand, the strong version of this critical argument says that there is ‘no evidence’ that mental health problems are biological and that saying that someone has ‘something wrong with their brain’ is demeaning or dehumanising in some way..."===https://mindhacks.com/
Reply
#2
C C Offline
In former times, the label of "illness" at least provided the preemptive faction with a justification for intervening on certain open-ended or developmentally deteriorating conditions before they got out of hand. Rather than waiting until illegal behaviors outright emerged: "Uh oh: The police hauled Bobby off after he stopped taking his medication and went out and cut the electric cables to the railroad crossing".

Nowadays, though, one might wonder what difference it makes in that respect: "Sorry, ma'am. We can't admit your son for treatment or take measures to insure that he takes his prescription drugs. Until he does something threatening to you or himself."

But an illness label is still the necessary qualification for receiving meds in the first place. As well as yielding the distinction of Oswald Cobblepot [Penguin] getting sent to Gotham’s Arkham Asylum as opposed to prison. Where though pronounced "cured" and released, he soon lapses back into old habits thanks to his wicked step family murdering his long-lost father for the latter's wealth.
Reply
#3
Magical Realist Online
Quote:As well as yielding the distinction of Oswald Cobblepot [Penguin] getting sent to Gotham’s Arkham Asylum as opposed to prison. Where though pronounced "cured" and released, he soon lapses back into old habits thanks to his wicked step family murdering his long-lost father for the latter's wealth.

I must confess to a vicarious sense of glee seeing Oswald reembrace his twisted Penguinine self. Such are the hazards of pissing off the chef. lol!
Reply
#4
C C Offline
(Apr 16, 2016 08:32 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: I must confess to a vicarious sense of glee seeing Oswald reembrace his twisted Penguinine self. Such are the hazards of pissing off the chef. lol!


Who would have expected Penguin to become the "star" of the show, or at least rival the supposedly two central characters in popularity? Since it could potentially be years yet before Cobblepot resembles the complete villain that the adult Batman faces, they ought to tone-him down during that interval to where he is "cured enough" to no longer slay innocent bystanders (just serve up those like his step-siblings as the main course for dinner). His non-selective killing was the biggest problem with the outlandishness of Gordon intermittently accepting him at times as if Cobblepot has one foot in the former's camp of morally ambiguous anti-heroes.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article Owning a pet does not reduce symptoms of severe mental illness, study shows C C 4 168 Jul 20, 2023 12:01 AM
Last Post: confused2
  The new meth and mental illness among the homeless Magical Realist 1 81 Feb 17, 2023 01:09 AM
Last Post: C C
  Genetic study confirms sarin nerve gas as cause of Gulf War illness C C 2 109 May 17, 2022 07:24 AM
Last Post: Kornee
  Microwave weapons may be behind Havana Syndrome: the mystery illness of US officials C C 1 134 Dec 9, 2020 12:55 AM
Last Post: C C
  Do antidepressants create more mental illness than they cure? (interview) C C 1 169 Jun 15, 2020 05:39 PM
Last Post: Syne
  How childhood infections & antibiotics may increase mental illness risk C C 0 316 Feb 23, 2019 02:03 AM
Last Post: C C
  Early cat ownership linked to mental illness Magical Realist 1 573 Nov 29, 2015 12:25 AM
Last Post: elte
  The stigma of mental illness is getting worse Magical Realist 1 837 Jul 12, 2015 03:46 PM
Last Post: Yazata
  How The Federal Government Destroyed The Mental Illness Treatment System C C 0 686 Nov 12, 2014 02:13 AM
Last Post: C C



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)