Article  Lamarck's self-making biological world is making a comeback?

#1
C C Offline
Long mocked and misunderstood, Lamarck’s radical idea that organisms shape themselves and their world is making a comeback
https://aeon.co/essays/the-self-making-w...te-lamarck

EXCERPTS: Throughout the history of modern biology, most powerful figures in science and politics have ridiculed and repressed Lamarck’s radical idea that organisms have agency in the evolutionary process. In mainstream biology today, a neo-Darwinian view of living things as passive still largely dominates, though research in several areas has been challenging its reign.

This is the story of how Lamarck’s radical idea was cast aside by mainstream science, and why it was overlooked for so long. It is also the story of a surprising reversal: in recent decades, some biologists have begun turning back toward Lamarck’s view of life.

[...] Lamarck’s idea of self-making and world-making organisms gained him powerful enemies. His nemesis was the palaeontologist Georges Cuvier, a favourite of Napoleon.

[...] Following Cuvier, many others ridiculed Lamarck’s science. Because it emerged in the midst of the French Revolution and replaced God with the creative agency of living organisms, it smelled to contemporaries of atheism, revolution and regicide. These ill odours promised trouble not only for Lamarck and Lamarckism but for evolutionary theory more generally.

[...] Neo-Darwinism, with its passive model of living beings, has been teetering on its throne. One current movement, known as the extended evolutionary synthesis, seeks to widen the evolutionary picture beyond the neo-Darwinist focus on random genetic variation and natural selection, in part by including behavioural and even cultural elements.

Many animals have something like what we call culture in humans, and this includes cultural forms that are inherited and passed down. Lamarck knew this. He wrote that intelligent animals – birds and mammals – could create new habits and ways of life that would be maintained over generations.

There is overwhelming and definitive evidence that all kinds of animals – birds, primates, whales, fish, insects – learn from one another and have cultural traditions that are handed down from generation to generation. Communication and social learning make a crucial difference to survival and reproduction, and therefore to evolution. Animals communicate vitally important things to one another including information about food, predators, songs, migration routes and where to find a mate. To give just one example... (MORE - missing details)
Reply
#2
confused2 Offline
I don't see how 'natural selection' in any way excludes the influence of behaviour. Sometimes the smartest of the species (or sometimes just the craziest) will be the ones to find new food sources and/or new behaviour patterns that are of advantage to the species .. which will be copied, bred and incorporated into the general species behaviour .. simply because those who adopt it prosper and those who don't tend to wither on the vine. This automatically falls within my definition of 'natural selection' .. is that contraversial?
Reply
#3
C C Offline
(Nov 4, 2026 11:49 PM)confused2 Wrote: I don't see how 'natural selection' in any way excludes the influence of behaviour. Sometimes the smartest of the species (or sometimes just the craziest) will be the ones to find new food sources and/or new behaviour patterns that are of advantage to the species .. which will be copied, bred and incorporated into the general species behaviour .. simply because those who adopt it prosper and those who don't tend to wither on the vine. This automatically falls within my definition of 'natural selection' .. is that contraversial?

Usually it's areas like epigenetics that try to resonate with Lamarckism. The idea of culture playing a role is new to me but has actually been around a while. Though it traditionally pertains to humans rather than animals, as this is trying to extend it to. If the group enforces a repeated behavior in its individuals, then I guess that selects for mutations arising in that group that facilitate enhancement of the activity slash ability. But it's coercion transpiring outside the body via the collective social influences (albeit habit-oriented information will ultimately be stored in brains).
- - - - - - - - - - - -

Dual inheritance theory (DIT), also known as gene–culture coevolution or biocultural evolution, developed in the 1960s through early 1980s to explain human behavior as a product of two different and interacting evolutionary processes: genetic evolution and cultural evolution. Genes and culture (DIT suggests) continually interact in a feedback loop: changes in genes can lead to changes in culture which can then influence genetic selection, and vice versa. One of the theory's central claims is that culture evolves partly through a Darwinian selection process, which dual-inheritance theorists often describe by analogy to genetic evolution.


Epigenetics has revived interest in Lamarckism by showing that traits acquired through environmental influences can sometimes be inherited across generations, although this inheritance is generally weak and does not fully align with Lamarck's original ideas. Modern research indicates that while epigenetic changes can occur, they are often a product of natural selection rather than a direct inheritance of acquired characteristics as Lamarck proposed.


Mechanisms resembling Lamarckism: In the 21st century, experimental results in the fields of epigenetics, genetics, and somatic hypermutation demonstrated the possibility of transgenerational epigenetic inheritance of traits acquired by the previous generation. These proved a limited validity of Lamarckism. The inheritance of the hologenome, consisting of the genomes of all an organism's symbiotic microbes as well as its own genome, is also somewhat Lamarckian in effect, though entirely Darwinian in its mechanisms.
Reply
#4
Syne Offline
Neo-Darwinism only covers biological genetic adaptation, not behavioral.
Reply
#5
confused2 Offline
(Nov 5, 2026 01:07 AM)Syne Wrote: Neo-Darwinism only covers biological genetic adaptation, not behavioral.
A theory about species drift that ignores (possibly) one of the main reasons for species drift .. is likely to be a crap theory.
Reply
#6
Syne Offline
(Nov 5, 2026 02:18 AM)confused2 Wrote:
(Nov 5, 2026 01:07 AM)Syne Wrote: Neo-Darwinism only covers biological genetic adaptation, not behavioral.
A theory about species drift that ignores (possibly) one of the main reasons for species drift .. is likely to be a crap theory.

I would agree, but many people have had no problem seeing all organisms as nothing but deterministic biological machines. You don't get culture-derived behavior from deterministic machines. That presumes a learning that genetics alone cannot account for.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article The idea of biological agency C C 0 481 Jul 10, 2026 12:05 AM
Last Post: C C
  Biological Evidence of Evolution: The Looping of the Vas Deferens Mohsen Ezz El-Din Al-Bakri 0 342 Jan 1, 2026 03:54 PM
Last Post: Mohsen Ezz El-Din Al-Bakri
  Article ‘The significant biological puzzle’ of sexual orientation (epigenetics & evolution) C C 1 819 Sep 19, 2023 07:20 PM
Last Post: Magical Realist
  A biological super glue from mistletoe berries? C C 0 611 Jun 15, 2022 12:10 AM
Last Post: C C
  WHO, US worry Ukrainian biological lab samples could spill, go to Russians C C 0 611 Mar 11, 2022 06:42 PM
Last Post: C C
  Regrowing amputated limbs closer to medical reality + Biological relativity C C 0 611 Jun 5, 2021 11:34 PM
Last Post: C C
  Is it possible for biological consciousness to wake up as a new consciousness? zhangjinyuan 8 2,451 Aug 4, 2020 02:36 PM
Last Post: confused2
  Tastier tomataoes comeback thanks to genetics + Our gen-engineered future is close C C 0 695 May 15, 2019 02:20 AM
Last Post: C C



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)