Posts: 15,033
Threads: 261
Joined: Aug 2016
Syne
Mar 28, 2026 04:00 AM
(This post was last modified: Mar 28, 2026 04:03 AM by Syne.)
The Marvels (2023): Co-written by Nia DaCosta, Megan McDonnell, and Elissa Karasik. The film was widely labeled "woke" by critics due to its female-led ensemble, and it became a major box office disappointment for Disney.
Charlie's Angels (2019): Written and directed by Elizabeth Banks. Often cited by critics as a "woke" failure due to its marketing and narrative focus on feminist themes, which resulted in a box office loss.
Eternals (2021): Co-written by Chloé Zhao, Patrick Burleigh, Ryan Firpo, and Kaz Firpo. It faced backlash for its diverse cast and inclusion of MCU's first openly gay character, contributing to a lower-than-expected box office return.
Pixar's Elio (2025 - Expected): Co-directed/written by Domee Shi. Early discussions surrounding the film have been framed within the "go woke, go broke" discourse, often aiming at its diverse creative team.
Star Trek: Starfleet Academy is created by Gaia Violo, with Alex Kurtzman and Noga Landau serving as showrunners. The writing team for the 2026 series includes experienced Trek writer Kirsten Beyer, Tawny Newsome, Kenneth Lin, Kiley Rossetter, and Eric Anthony Glover.
- Google AI
Posts: 18,146
Threads: 3,240
Joined: Oct 2014
Magical Realist
Mar 28, 2026 05:22 AM
(This post was last modified: Mar 28, 2026 05:52 AM by Magical Realist.)
So which of these are by authors/screenwriters? That was your claim. Now back it up. And how does this relate in any way to Colbert's new job? Are you claiming Jackson hired him because of affirmative action? lol
Posts: 15,033
Threads: 261
Joined: Aug 2016
Syne
Mar 28, 2026 06:24 AM
(Mar 28, 2026 05:22 AM)Magical Realist Wrote: So which of these are by authors/screenwriters? That was your claim. Now back it up. "Co-written by, written by, writing team." Learn to read.
Quote:And how does this relate in any way to Colbert's new job? Are you claiming Jackson hired him because of affirmative action? lol
There sure isn't any past work of his that merits an IP and budget like LOTR.
Now, if they just need some new schlock, like War of the Rohirrim or Hunt for Golem, to maintain their ownership of the IP*, it really doesn't matter if it's any good.
*Many IPs are conditional on making content using that IP every so many years, otherwise you lose the rights.
Posts: 18,146
Threads: 3,240
Joined: Oct 2014
Magical Realist
Mar 28, 2026 05:59 PM
(This post was last modified: Mar 28, 2026 06:00 PM by Magical Realist.)
Quote:"Co-written by, written by, writing team." Learn to read.
Nothing saying they're authors/screenwriters .
Quote:There sure isn't any past work of his that merits an IP and budget like LOTR.
Like I've said before dumbass, every screenwriter has their first screenplay. And Colbert is an aficionado of Tolkien as well as an author. Which makes him more than qualified.
Posts: 15,033
Threads: 261
Joined: Aug 2016
Syne
Mar 28, 2026 09:01 PM
(Mar 28, 2026 05:59 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: Quote:"Co-written by, written by, writing team." Learn to read.
Nothing saying they're authors/screenwriters . That's the definition of screenwriter, dipshit loser.
Quote:Quote:There sure isn't any past work of his that merits an IP and budget like LOTR.
Like I've said before dumbass, every screenwriter has their first screenplay. And Colbert is an aficionado of Tolkien as well as an author. Which makes him more than qualified.
Where's the script he's selling on its merits? Without prior screenwriting experience relevant to the project, that's how first-time screenwriters get work.
Some of these Tolkien experts are authors too:
Top Tolkien experts include acclaimed scholars like Tom Shippey (author of The Road to Middle-earth) and Dr. Corey Olsen ("The Tolkien Professor"), along with esteemed researchers such as Verlyn Flieger, John Rateliff, Wayne Hammond, and Christina Scull. These experts specialize in Tolkien's philology, literature, and the "legendarium".
- Google AI
What makes Colbert more qualified? You know, other than your crush on him.
Posts: 18,146
Threads: 3,240
Joined: Oct 2014
Magical Realist
Mar 28, 2026 09:04 PM
(This post was last modified: Mar 28, 2026 09:21 PM by Magical Realist.)
Quote:Where's the script he's selling on its merits? Without prior screenwriting experience relevant to the project, that's how first-time screenwriters get work.
He was hired to co-write the script so he hasn't written it yet. Like I said 5 times now every screenwriter has his first screenplay. Taylor Sheridan's was "Hell or High Water". Add to that the fact that Jackson and Colbert are friends who know each other well, and there ya have it. Most the time it isn't what you know but who you know.
Quote:What makes Colbert more qualified? You know, other than your crush on him.
Script writing and a long history of demonstrated creativity and expertise in produced TV shows and his 10 year old own talk show. It's how a Tolkien expert becomes a screenwriter.
Posts: 15,033
Threads: 261
Joined: Aug 2016
Syne
Mar 28, 2026 10:19 PM
(Mar 28, 2026 09:04 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: Quote:Where's the script he's selling on its merits? Without prior screenwriting experience relevant to the project, that's how first-time screenwriters get work.
He was hired to co-write the script so he hasn't written it yet. Like I said 5 times now every screenwriter has his first screenplay. Taylor Sheridan's was "Hell or High Water". Again, Sheridan wrote Sicario and then Hell or High Water, selling the latter first.
Nothing like Colbert, who has nothing to sell.
Quote:Add to that the fact that Jackson and Colbert are friends who know each other well, and there ya have it. Most the time it isn't what you know but who you know.
So nepotism. Got it.
Quote:Quote:What makes Colbert more qualified? You know, other than your crush on him.
Script writing and a long history of demonstrated creativity and expertise in produced TV shows and his 10 year old own talk show. It's how a Tolkien expert becomes a screenwriter.
Plenty of veteran TV show producers never get offered a feature film out of the blue.
Man, you must really have it bad for Colbert.
Posts: 18,146
Threads: 3,240
Joined: Oct 2014
Magical Realist
Mar 28, 2026 10:38 PM
(This post was last modified: Mar 29, 2026 12:15 AM by Magical Realist.)
Quote:Again, Sheridan wrote Sicario and then Hell or High Water, selling the latter first.
Hell or High Water was his first sale. No resume of screenwriting or anything. Imagine that.
Quote:Nothing like Colbert, who has nothing to sell.
Right. He's selling his services as a screenwriter, not an already written screenplay. Keep up with the thread.
Quote:Plenty of veteran TV show producers never get offered a feature film out of the blue
So fuck'n what? I'm sure plenty have been offered a feature film out of the blue too. Why are you bitching about it? It's like explaining things to a 10 yr old. I think you're done here.
Posts: 15,033
Threads: 261
Joined: Aug 2016
Syne
Mar 29, 2026 01:57 AM
(Mar 28, 2026 10:38 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: Quote:Again, Sheridan wrote Sicario and then Hell or High Water, selling the latter first.
Hell or High Water was his first sale. No resume of screenwriting or anything. Imagine that. How many times do I have to say it? He had a script, and sold it on its merits.
He didn't have a screenwriting job just drop in his lap.
Quote:Quote:Nothing like Colbert, who has nothing to sell.
Right. He's selling his services as a screenwriter, not an already written screenplay. Keep up with the thread.
With no resume to merit those services on a big budget feature film.
You're the one who keep bringing up Sheridan, who had already written screenplays. That's the whole distinction I've been making all along. Why, are you just now figuring that out? @_@
Quote:Quote:Plenty of veteran TV show producers never get offered a feature film out of the blue
So fuck'n what? I'm sure plenty have been offered a feature film out of the blue too. Why are you bitching about it? It's like explaining things to a 10 yr old. I think you're done here.
Oh, the projection is so thick. 9_9
Posts: 18,146
Threads: 3,240
Joined: Oct 2014
Magical Realist
Mar 29, 2026 02:12 AM
(This post was last modified: Mar 29, 2026 02:18 AM by Magical Realist.)
Quote:You're the one who keep bringing up Sheridan, who had already written screenplays. That's the whole distinction I've been making all along.
Nope..he wrote one screenplay and put it in a drawer. So he had no "written screenplays"--only one, which he didn't show to anyone. Tell me how that amounts to a screenwriting resume:
"Sheridan wrote his very first script when he was 40 years old. Sicario, written on spec, was then put into a drawer to write what he felt would be an easier script to sell. That script was the Oscar-nominated Hell or High Water."
Quote:With no resume to merit those services on a big budget feature film.
Sheridan didn't have a resume to merit his first film either. I guess he wasn't qualified either. lol
"Based on the provided search results, Taylor Sheridan did not have a traditional, accomplished resume when he transitioned into screenwriting for his first major film, Sicario (2015)...He effectively built his reputation as a top-tier writer and director from scratch after quitting acting, rather than relying on a previously established writing resume."
|