Posts: 909
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2017
Oct 19, 2019 01:19 AM
(This post was last modified: Oct 19, 2019 01:20 AM by confused2.)
This kind of thing plays out in every "Do animals have feeelings?" discussion.
Let us share a moment with Syne and his dog.
Syne>"Tell daddy what you think empathy is.".
Cuddles>"Woof?".
Syne>"Well I guess that proves you don't know what empathy is.".
Likewise altruism, 'love', 'family', affection, devotion and so on.
Posts: 5,368
Threads: 112
Joined: Aug 2016
C2 seems to have missed where I'm the one saying animals have a similarity to people...and MR saying otehrwise.
Well, can't account for poor reading comprehension.
Posts: 909
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2017
Syne, you were thrust onto the stage in your capacity as a representative of 'Everyman' - in context a representative of 'Everyman' that shares their life with a dog (or any other animal) that can't talk. In the absence of a common language we are left to interpret what we see, what we think we see and what we think we know.
If you can prove animals have a similarity to people (I assume you mean a significant similarity) then please take the stage again.
Posts: 5,368
Threads: 112
Joined: Aug 2016
No one implied your straw man that anyone could prove a "significant" similarity. And this straw man seems to be you weaseling your way out of your previous misconstrual of who was making which argument. Shame on you.
Posts: 909
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2017
I will admit the possibility of some overlap (confusion) with "Consciousness does not depend on language.". That aside your qualification for the role of Straw Syne was that you have a dog (at least I think you do) and you aren't SS (not making that mistake again). Your previous convictions weren't taken into account.
