9 hours ago
https://www.sciencealert.com/scientists-...-skeletons
INTRO: There's something strange about some of the skeletons buried in monasteries in Denmark. Some seem to date back decades – or even centuries – before their final resting places were even built. So what's going on?
Scientists from the University of Southern Denmark and the Center for Isotope Research believe they've found the answer. In a comment article published in npj Heritage Science, they've issued "words of warning" for archaeologists when dating medieval human remains. Radiocarbon dating is a fairly reliable method for calculating the age of bones and artifacts, up to about 50,000 years.
The process begins in space: cosmic rays interact with nitrogen in the atmosphere, producing small amounts of a specific isotope called carbon-14, which then binds with atmospheric oxygen to form carbon dioxide. Trees and other photosynthesizing plants then absorb this carbon from the air into their own cells, and in turn, so do the animals that eat those plants (as well as the animals that eat other animals that eat plants).
When those animals eventually die, they obviously stop eating and therefore stop adding new carbon-14 to their cells. From there, the carbon-14 levels can only decrease over time through radioactive decay. By analyzing the carbon-14 levels inside bones and comparing them to known historical levels of the isotope in the atmosphere, scientists can calculate fairly accurately how old those bones are.
But there's a problem. Regular radiocarbon dating works well for humans and animals that largely eat land animals and plants, but it's a different story for those who eat a lot of fish, thanks to a phenomenon known as the 'reservoir effect'.
Rivers, lakes, and oceans have different ratios of carbon isotopes, due to dissolved carbonate runoff or upwelling of much older carbon dioxide. That means that rivers, for instance, can contain around 15 percent less carbon-14 than the atmosphere. As a result, the bones of a person with a fish-heavy diet can appear to be hundreds of years older than they really are... (MORE - details)
INTRO: There's something strange about some of the skeletons buried in monasteries in Denmark. Some seem to date back decades – or even centuries – before their final resting places were even built. So what's going on?
Scientists from the University of Southern Denmark and the Center for Isotope Research believe they've found the answer. In a comment article published in npj Heritage Science, they've issued "words of warning" for archaeologists when dating medieval human remains. Radiocarbon dating is a fairly reliable method for calculating the age of bones and artifacts, up to about 50,000 years.
The process begins in space: cosmic rays interact with nitrogen in the atmosphere, producing small amounts of a specific isotope called carbon-14, which then binds with atmospheric oxygen to form carbon dioxide. Trees and other photosynthesizing plants then absorb this carbon from the air into their own cells, and in turn, so do the animals that eat those plants (as well as the animals that eat other animals that eat plants).
When those animals eventually die, they obviously stop eating and therefore stop adding new carbon-14 to their cells. From there, the carbon-14 levels can only decrease over time through radioactive decay. By analyzing the carbon-14 levels inside bones and comparing them to known historical levels of the isotope in the atmosphere, scientists can calculate fairly accurately how old those bones are.
But there's a problem. Regular radiocarbon dating works well for humans and animals that largely eat land animals and plants, but it's a different story for those who eat a lot of fish, thanks to a phenomenon known as the 'reservoir effect'.
Rivers, lakes, and oceans have different ratios of carbon isotopes, due to dissolved carbonate runoff or upwelling of much older carbon dioxide. That means that rivers, for instance, can contain around 15 percent less carbon-14 than the atmosphere. As a result, the bones of a person with a fish-heavy diet can appear to be hundreds of years older than they really are... (MORE - details)
