Article  A God's eye view is made impossible by quantum mechanics?

#1
C C Offline
https://iai.tv/articles/a-gods-eye-view-..._auid=2020

INTRO: Many scientists and philosophers seek to provide an overall account of the world, often described as a God's eye view, that aims to picture how the universe is as a whole. In this piece, theoretical physicist Eric Cavalcanti argues that quantum mechanics throws a wrench into this idea. Using a simple thought experiment, he shows that at the heart of quantum mechanics, there is a paradox that prevents a God's eye view. The upshot is: reality is different for everyone. (MORE - details)
Reply
#2
confused2 Offline
I smell witchcraft.
Extra cats!

"..she asks Quall-E what it saw, and finds that its report reads either “live cat” or “dead cat”, with 50% probability each. Tails, she will instruct her quantum computer to reverse the computation through which Quall-E observed the cat, thereby erasing Quall-E’s memory of it."

To 'reverse' it you have to start with another cat .. the first cat is either alive or dead .. OR it was never detected which is a can of worms you can't dismiss so easily.. if you don't detect the cat you can't just pretend to have a report based on detection.
Reply
#3
Magical Realist Offline
Quote:We can still have objectivity without absoluteness. We can still do physics from within a relational world. What we may have to give up is the narrator who stands outside it.

Well put and highly thought-provoking. We all encounter a kind of objective reality that is also entirely relative to the event of our being conscious of it. We call it the future. Objective in the sense that it embraces all possibilities and probabilities much like a wavefunction or a multiverse, but relative and non-absolute in the sense of only becoming actualized in relation to a certain standpoint or subject. Omnipresence without omniscience as it were.
Reply
#4
Magical Realist Offline
"All that my pluralism contends for is that there is no where extant a complete gathering up of the universe in one focus, either of knowledge, power, or purpose. Something escapes, even from God.” --William James, letter to Minot Judson Savage, January, 1910 [1]

I'm impressed how William James honed in on the typical mistake of both philosophers and scientists to totalize all experience into one thing--one substance or property or abstract concept--when experience suggests nothing of the sort. Reacting both to the Hegelian project of one absolute truth or omniscient point of view and the rise of scientific materialism as the universalization of physical matter/energy as THE objective universe, he wisely urged a return to events and objects themselves again in all their given looseness and resistance to overarching generalizations. No longer a monism of one absolute unity of everything, but a pluralism where diversity and kinds and perspectives also play an important role in our understanding of experience. Acknowledging possible conjunctions between phenonema while preserving their essentially disjunctive and individual presentation to our consciousness. No closing off of language inside its own theoretical and propositional frameworks but a remaining exposed and open to the raw phenomena and distinctive qualitative feel of consciousness itself. Pluralism as a necessary metaphysical extrapolation from the phenomenological vision of pure description and dialectical sense-making.

"I want to say here that it can never be our job to reduce anything to anything, or to explain anything. Philosophy really is 'purely descriptive.'"----Wittgenstein
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article QBism and the philosophical crisis of quantum mechanics C C 0 701 Oct 6, 2023 04:26 PM
Last Post: C C
  It is impossible to step out of the real world Ostronomos 1 705 Mar 27, 2023 09:52 PM
Last Post: Ostronomos
  A guide to (not) understanding quantum mechanics (leave it at magic or not?) C C 4 1,440 Feb 17, 2023 04:01 PM
Last Post: confused2
  For the agnostic... what God, quantum mechanics & consciousness have in common C C 2 984 Aug 16, 2021 08:06 PM
Last Post: Leigha
  Quantum mechanics, free will & the Game of Life (John Horgon) C C 47 13,068 Feb 22, 2021 06:39 PM
Last Post: Syne



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)