Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Mathematical fictionalism

#1
Magical Realist Offline
"Fictionalism in mathematics was brought to fame in 1980 when Hartry Field published Science Without Numbers, which rejected and in fact reversed Quine's indispensability argument. Where Quine suggested that mathematics was indispensable for our best scientific theories, and therefore should be accepted as a body of truths talking about independently existing entities, Field suggested that mathematics was dispensable, and therefore should be considered as a body of falsehoods not talking about anything real. He did this by giving a complete axiomatization of Newtonian mechanics with no reference to numbers or functions at all. He started with the "betweenness" of Hilbert's axioms to characterize space without coordinatizing it, and then added extra relations between points to do the work formerly done by vector fields. Hilbert's geometry is mathematical, because it talks about abstract points, but in Field's theory, these points are the concrete points of physical space, so no special mathematical objects at all are needed.

Having shown how to do science without using numbers, Field proceeded to rehabilitate mathematics as a kind of useful fiction. He showed that mathematical physics is a conservative extension of his non-mathematical physics (that is, every physical fact provable in mathematical physics is already provable from Field's system), so that mathematics is a reliable process whose physical applications are all true, even though its own statements are false. Thus, when doing mathematics, we can see ourselves as telling a sort of story, talking as if numbers existed. For Field, a statement like "2 + 2 = 4" is just as fictitious as "Sherlock Holmes lived at 221B Baker Street"—but both are true according to the relevant fictions.

By this account, there are no metaphysical or epistemological problems special to mathematics. The only worries left are the general worries about non-mathematical physics, and about fiction in general. Field's approach has been very influential, but is widely rejected. This is in part because of the requirement of strong fragments of second-order logic to carry out his reduction, and because the statement of conservativity seems to require quantification over abstract models or deductions."===https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophy_of_mathematics
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Mathematical Metaphysics Revisited Ostronomos 0 107 Mar 30, 2021 09:21 PM
Last Post: Ostronomos
  A reality theoretic extension of Logic/ mathematical proof of God Ostronomos 0 118 Feb 23, 2021 07:28 PM
Last Post: Ostronomos
  The mathematical reduction of reality to axioms makes it axionmatisable Ostronomos 1 217 Nov 5, 2019 12:28 AM
Last Post: Ostronomos
  All mathematical points have the same reality Ostronomos 2 447 Dec 29, 2017 10:29 PM
Last Post: RainbowUnicorn
  The mathematical world + Why is linguistics a magnet for dilettantes & crackpots? C C 0 376 Sep 16, 2017 06:20 PM
Last Post: C C



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)