Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Oceanic auroras

#1
Magical Realist Offline
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2004/apr/01/farout

"It's often said that we know outer space better than the depths of our own oceans. Certainly they're home to some little-understood natural phenomena, of which none is more dazzling than the lightwheels.

These spectacular submarine lightshows range in size from a few metres across to filling the entire visible ocean with phosphorescent colour. They take many forms: long, straight bands stretching across the horizon; simple rings and ellipses; concentric circles that pulsate from a brightly glowing centre; and curving, spoked wheels which rotate, sometimes at dizzying speeds. The displays can last a few minutes or several hours, with numerous patterns appearing in sequence, or even simultaneously.

The Marine Observer, the journal of the marine division of the Met Office, contains detailed reports of lightwheel observations going back more than a century; but no expeditions have set out specifically to study them.

Ordinary bioluminescent surface phenomena are seen most often in warmer waters like the Persian Gulf, the Indian Ocean and the South China Sea. Generally occurring between March and June, they consist of millions of micro-organisms and larger plankton that drift near the ocean surface. These micro-organisms glow when shaken or disturbed, lighting up the wakes and bow waves of ships, or the crests of waves, sometimes forming great milky blankets over the sea. Less common are balls of light and long worm-like shapes seen glowing underwater, as described by Thor Heyerdahl on his 1947 Kon-Tiki voyage; these have been attributed to shoals or large single fish moving among the luminous organisms.

But the huge rings and wheels appear more rarely, and their cause remains undetermined. Some have connected the pulsating signal-like patterns to the communications devices on ships and submarines, but lightwheel reports pre-date radar and sonar, even radio. Others have attributed the patterns to whale communication, tectonic movement, geomagnetic pulses from the earth's core or, more fancifully, to the beacons of a great submarine civilisation. We can guess, but we just don't know. Awe-inspiring and beautiful, unfilmed and unphotographed, the lightwheels remain an unfathomable mystery."
Reply
#2
Kornee Offline
A scholarly attempt to provide a range of plausible explanations:
https://www.staff.science.uu.nl/~maas013...us2014.pdf
At least there is an honest acknowledgement of their limitations in part 6: Conclusion:

In this thesis the varying theories that have been put forward to explain the phenomena known as marine lightwheels and light balls have been analysed and
discussed. It has become clear that even though most theories do provide a decent explanation for the phenomena at first sight, a closer look shows that
they all fall short in explaining some aspects of the observations. This either means that the final theory concerning the phenomena has not yet been found,
or that different versions of the phenomena also need different theories. This last option may seem like a stretch, because the different phenomena all seem to take place in the same area and in the same time frame, which would indicate that the different theories that have been discussed should all have the same very specific requirements. However, using the same explanation for all of the different observations is also unsatisfying, because of the great variation between them. For example, the different lightwheels may all seem like the same phenomenon because of their great resemblance to each other, but is a lightwheel that is centred and fixed on an arbitrary point really the same as one centred on and moving along with a ship?......

I recall coming across such bizarre encounters being reported by Soviet era submarine and surface naval vessel crew who logged many such incidents.
Reply




Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)