Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Critique topples Nature paper on belief in gods

#1
C C Offline
https://retractionwatch.com/2021/07/07/c...f-in-gods/

EXCERPTS: A widely-touted 2019 study in Nature which argued that large societies gave rise to belief in fire-and-brimstone gods — and not the other way around — has been retracted by the authors after their reanalysis of the data in the wake of criticism diluted the strength of their conclusions.

The article, “Complex societies precede moralizing gods throughout world history,” came from a group of scholars in the United Kingdom, the United States and elsewhere, and was led by Harvey Whitehouse, an anthropologist and the the director of the Centre for the Study of Social Cohesion at the University of Oxford.

The study prompted a significant amount of interest on social media and in the global press [...] As Scientific American put it, Whitehouse’s group found that the advent of moralizing gods did not lead to the formation of complex societies. Rather: "the study suggests pro-social religions appeared after complex societies had already emerged. Although these religions may have helped sustain and grow large societies, the analysis makes the case that they were not necessary for societies to expand in the first place."

[...] Immediately after publication, a group led by Bret Beheim ... submitted a response to the journal questioning the validity of the results. ... "the original paper treats absence of evidence for moralizing gods as evidence of their absence." (link)

[...] After reanalyzing their results in light of the challenge, Whitehouse’s group agreed that the findings weren’t quite as robust as they’d initially claimed.

Beheim told us [...] "I look forward to reading the … revised argument. The objection I had to the original analysis wasn’t so much their conclusion, but that they weren’t transparent about the amount of missing data involved. If our critique can help them nail that problem down, I think the field will progress. " (MORE - details)
Reply
#2
Syne Offline
Could have predicted that. But even though they claim it prompted significant interest, I never heard about it.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article Why are most of us stuck with a belief in the soul? C C 2 87 Apr 1, 2023 08:29 PM
Last Post: Magical Realist
  Belonging among the beasts & gods in Mayan cosmology C C 0 64 Oct 12, 2021 04:22 PM
Last Post: C C
  ‘Religious’ exemptions & vaccine mandates + Biden's belief flip-flop on abortion C C 10 328 Sep 11, 2021 02:46 AM
Last Post: Syne
  Unconscious learning underlies belief in God, study suggests C C 1 123 Sep 9, 2020 11:27 PM
Last Post: Syne
  Religion origins: How did belief evolve? C C 2 195 Mar 4, 2020 12:51 AM
Last Post: Magical Realist
  Rubenstein rethinking modern cosmology leaving no room for gods (video) C C 0 135 Jan 24, 2020 09:27 PM
Last Post: C C
  Tomorrow's gods: What is the future of religion? (explored in multiple sections) C C 0 274 Aug 8, 2019 03:59 AM
Last Post: C C
  The new gods: Are celebrities killing traditional religions? + Jesus & abortion C C 1 713 Jul 7, 2018 11:11 PM
Last Post: Syne
  Imaginings: Battling the Gods - Atheism in the Ancient World C C 2 1,059 Nov 27, 2016 06:54 AM
Last Post: Syne
  Can religion be practice rather than belief? + Do animals have souls? C C 20 2,699 Oct 26, 2016 04:17 AM
Last Post: Syne



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)