(Nov 5, 2018 12:34 AM)Magical Realist Wrote: [ -> ]Here are some more bad ideas of religion that involve doctrine:
1) Original sin--the idea that humans inherit immorality and sin from Adam.
I don't believe in a literal Adam, but it doesn't seem to be entirely wrong if we interpret 'Adam' to mean 'our distant evolutionary ancestry'.
Quote:2) The evil of contraception--the idea that birth control is wrong.
Reducing our longer-term reproductive fitness doesn't seem like a great idea in evolutionary terms. It's just ceding the future to populations that produce more offspring.
In our modern world, wealth, education and female liberation are all seen as positives, yet they all contribute to lower birthrates below replacement levels. It's countries where these things are least prevalent that are growing fastest.
Quote:4) Moral conversion--the idea that anybody, even a murderer, can be made righteous by believing in Jesus.
Not all religions emphasize Jesus, so it's just stupid to identify 'religion' with 'Christianity'. But there is a point to it. What matters most in the ethical sense is what people do
now, not what they did
yesterday. No matter what you did yesterday, you can still get your life in order now, going forward. If somebody is a sinner, even a murderer, then the goal is to change.
Which brings up:
Quote:7) Atonement--the idea that an innocent person can be punished in your stead for your sins.
If we reject the idea that a person can simply reform after committing a great sin like murder, if we still believe that there needs to be some consequence for great transgression, then we are embracing the idea of atonement, the idea that there's a debt to be paid. The word 'atonement' comes from Old English, where it literally means 'at-one-ment'. It's about making things right, earning forgiveness and restoring social harmony (in an early medieval society in which blood feuds were a big danger).
Certainly the idea that somebody else can pay the price for you does seem kind of bogus. But we see the idea in many early cultures. In Islamic law, murder isn't a crime, it's a tort. The family of a murdered person can sue the family of the murderer for damages. Often that meant cash payment or the opportunity to kill the murderer or one of his close relatives. The latter has obvious ethical defects, but it served to defuse the lingering generations-long blood feuds between Bedouin tribes.
Quote:5) Apocalypse--the destruction of all mankind and the salvation of God's believers in his new paradise.
Apocalypse is a dream of revolutionaries everywhere. Just look at Marxism and its awaited 'Revolution' that would supposedly make everything right, end all social divisions (which 'historical materialism' attributed to class) and introduce a permanent Paradise. So the idea of a great triumphant battle when good will finally defeat evil isn't just a religious idea, it's a political-revolutionary idea.
Inter-testamental Judaism is where the apocalyptic ideas arose. It was a time after Alexander the Great's conquest of the Middle East, when Greek ideas were spreading everywhere and seemed to threaten traditional Judaism. Then the Romans conquered the area. That's the context of the book of Revelations and apocalyptic dreams led to two disastrous Jewish wars in 70CE and 130CE, revolutions against Rome that resulted in Jews being exiled from the 'Holy Land' for almost 2,000 years.
Quote:6) Healing--the idea that diseases and conditions can be cured by prayer and laying on of hands.
Not a bad idea when medical science didn't exist. Even today, more of health is psychosomatic than many people recognize. One's mental state has a big influence on one's health.
Quote:9) Faith--the idea that believing in something without evidence or logic is a virtue.
It isn't so much a virtue as a necessity.
Very little (almost nothing) in our lives or in our belief systems is solidly nailed-down. Yet we have to commit ourselves and behave as if we have it all figured out and know what to do.
Science seems rock-solid in many people's lives, and we see people fighting tooth-and-nail to preserve that faith on other boards. But science is based on many metaphysical assumptions that are going to be hard to conclusively justify. Not only metaphysical assumptions, but logical assumptions too. If we push too hard, it all seems to reduce to intuition and little more.