Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum

Full Version: Tweak to Schrödinger's cat could unite Einstein's relativity and quantum mechanics
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
This doesn't really sound like anything new, apart from maybe the proposal of collapse at "regular intervals". Sans any interaction being necessary?
- - - - - - - - - -

Tweak to Schrödinger's cat equation could unite Einstein's relativity and quantum mechanics, study hints
https://www.livescience.com/physics-math...tudy-hints

EXCERPT: . . . Crucially, these modifications have little impact on microscopic quantum systems, such as atoms and molecules, but allow larger systems — like the universe itself — to collapse at frequent intervals, giving them definite values that fit with our observations of the cosmos. The team described their modified Schrödinger equation in February in the Journal of High Energy Physics.

In their tweaked version of quantum physics, the researchers eliminated the distinction between objects subject to measurement and measuring devices. Instead, they proposed that each system's state undergoes spontaneous collapse at regular intervals, leading to the acquisition of definite values for some of their attributes.

For large systems, spontaneous collapse occurs frequently, rendering them classical in appearance. Subatomic objects interacting with these systems become part of them, leading to rapid collapse of their state and the acquisition of definite coordinates, akin to measurement.

"With no action from external entities, any system localizes (or collapses) spontaneously in a particular state. In place of having a cat being dead AND alive, one finds it dead OR alive," Carlesso said.

The new model may explain why our universe's space-time geometry doesn't exist in a superposition of states and obeys the classical equations of Einstein's relativity.

"Our model describes a quantum Universe, which eventually collapsed thus becoming effectively classical," Carlesso said. "We show that spontaneous collapse models can explain the emergence of a classical Universe from a quantum superposition of Universes, where each of these Universes has a different space-time geometry."

While this theory may explain why the universe seems to be governed by classical laws of physics, it doesn't make new predictions about large-scale physical processes... (MORE - missing details)
Closer, but still missing the point.
I agree that collapse occurs at regular intervals for classical objects, but they seem to fall short of the implications for quantum mechanics.
How can a quantum system continue to evolve through many such collapses?
Because these collapses are a fundamental function of QM, not solely isolated to large classic objects. Collapse and spread of the wave function are just two different ways of looking at the same thing.
Looking at the double slit experiment ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-slit_experiment ) .. a spontaneous collapse of the wave function would suggest a photon would have to go through one slit or the other not (as observed) both. If the wave function collapses at 'regular intervals' we should find light from distant sources doesn't even produce a diffraction pattern .. but it does.
Diffraction patterns in astronomical imaging .. https://mariotonin.me/2022/07/diffractio...l-imaging/