Article  Why science & its journals should remain free of ideology: an example from "Nature"

C C Offline

EXCERPTS (Jerry Coyne): It’s one thing for a newspaper to take political stands, but that’s okay only in the editorial section. So long as the “news” section—the reporting itself—remains untainted by political leanings or obvious bias, people can still trust the news, even if they use editorials to diss entire papers like the NYT as “authoritarian leftist” or the Wall Street Journal as “right wing”. The important thing is to keep the editorial section completely separate from the news.

But it’s another thing entirely for scientific journals to take political stands, and this post should show you why...

[...] This is what happened to Scientific American, which, once free from politics, has under its new leadership decided to repeatedly take woke stands in their editorials, and that has made the whole magazine lose credibility. Can you trust their judgement about what science they choose to publish if their editorials accuse Mendel of racism? (They did that, but of course it’s a lie.) Best to keep political views out of science journals, whose purpose, after all, is not to render political opinions but to convey scientific truth.

But it’s even worse when it happens in a serious journal like Nature, for, unlike Scientific American, Nature publishes new scientific results. By steering clear of ideological stands in the rest of the journal, it can at least be free of the criticism that it’s publishing biased science.

And for years Nature pretty much refrained from politics, probably because it realized that its mission was the dissemination of science, not social engineering. The journal was first published in 1869, and remained fairly unpolitical until 2016...

[...] And loss of scientific credibility did in fact happen. Nature itself admits this in an article published two days ago, “Political endorsements can affect scientific credibility.”... (MORE - missing details)

RELATED: Hard truths about journal prestige ..... eLife's quest to upend science publishing

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  Article Coyne: Most extreme incursion of ideology into ecology & evolution I've ever seen C C 0 8 Jun 3, 2023 02:25 PM
Last Post: C C
  Article Once again, Scientific American ideology distorts science: "Animal sex is not binary" C C 0 12 May 19, 2023 02:05 PM
Last Post: C C
Last Post: Kornee
  Controlled experiments show doctors dismissing evidence due to ideology C C 1 13 Feb 11, 2023 01:24 AM
Last Post: confused2
  Ideology stomps all over chemistry in a new paper C C 0 36 Jan 17, 2023 03:38 AM
Last Post: C C
  "Science is political": Defending its soapbox antics, SciAm fully looses its cred? C C 1 265 Nov 12, 2022 06:10 AM
Last Post: Kornee
  A political ideology infused paper on how to teach college biology C C 0 251 Oct 20, 2022 12:44 AM
Last Post: C C
  Science destroys its credibility by embracing critical theory C C 1 237 Oct 14, 2022 02:33 PM
Last Post: Kornee
  Earth Day 2022: Doomsday isn't at the corner + Earth Day polluted by woo & ideology C C 0 17 Apr 19, 2022 06:46 PM
Last Post: C C
  Should we get rid of the scientific paper, & its resulting problems & temptations? C C 0 14 Apr 14, 2022 08:29 PM
Last Post: C C

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)