+- Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum (https://www.scivillage.com)
+-- Forum: Culture (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-49.html)
+--- Forum: Religions & Spirituality (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-124.html)
+--- Thread: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight (/thread-6518.html)
“Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - C C - Dec 17, 2018
http://www.exeter.ac.uk/news/featurednews/title_697103_en.html
EXCERPT: . . . Professor Boyle received 1,200 responses from all around the world to his The Exeter Santa Survey, the only international study of its kind, mainly from adults reflecting on their childhood memories.
Interim findings show:
34 per cent of people wished that they still believed in Santa with 50 per cent quite content that they no longer believe
Around 34 per cent of those who took part in the survey said believing in Father Christmas had improved their behaviour as a child whilst 47 per cent found it did not
The average age when children stopped believing in Father Christmas was 8.
There are significant differences between England and Scotland. The mean age when people stop believing in Father Christmas was 8.03 for England and 8.58 in Scotland. There was a difference in attitudes between England and Scotland, as to whether it is ok to lie to children about Santa - more people in Scotland than in England said it was ok to lie to children about Santa.
A total of 65 per cent of people had played along with the Santa myth, as children, even though they knew it wasn’t true.
A third of respondents said they had been upset when they discovered Father Christmas wasn’t real, while 15 per cent had felt betrayed by their parents and ten per cent were angry.
Around 56 per cent of respondents said their trust in adults hadn’t been affected by their belief in Father Christmas, while 30 per cent said it had.
A total of 31 per cent of parents said they had denied that Santa is not true when directlyasked by their child, while 40 per cent hadn’t denied it if they are asked directly.
A total of 72 per cent of parents are quite happy telling their children about Santa and playing along with the myth, with the rest choosing not to.
Professor Boyle said: “During the last two years I have been overwhelmed by people getting in touch to say they were affected by the lack of trust involved when they discovered Santa wasn’t real....
MORE (details): http://www.exeter.ac.uk/news/featurednews/title_697103_en.html
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - confused2 - Dec 17, 2018
From http://www.exeter.ac.uk/news/featurednew...03_en.html
Quote:Professor Boyle said: “During the last two years I have been overwhelmed by people getting in touch to say they were affected by the lack of trust involved when they discovered Santa wasn’t real....When you find the guy that you thought gave unselfishly turns out to be your parents - is that really a let-down? Like when parents call their parents Grandma or Granny and so on when their child is present - this is out of respect for their parents position in the childs life - nobody calls their mother 'granny' - it would be absurd. We have to guess that parents who perpetuate the Santa myth went through the rite themselves - the only possible reason to inflict the myth on their children is that they liked it and continue to like it as adults.
#FooledbySanta - my heart bleeds.
In a few years time the child will be getting a manky second hand bike (guess how I know) which is all their parents can afford and it will be the childs turn to lie - for the same reason their parents lied.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - Zinjanthropos - Dec 18, 2018
Quote:In a few years time the child will be getting a manky second hand bike (guess how I know) which is all their parents can afford and it will be the childs turn to lie - for the same reason their parents lied.
Has the experience turned you into The Grinch, C2? Were you a bad boy, a used bike being a substitute for a lump of coal?
My long departed F-I-L always gave my kids used stuff, even things he purloined from the curb, toys that people were tossing out. My kids didn't know any different.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - confused2 - Dec 19, 2018
Z Wrote:Were you a bad boy?Even now there's a part of me that wants to respond with:-
"Please don't hurt me - I promise to be good from now on." - that may be an adult (learned) response - I am too far from the child to know how a child actually feels. I can say that when my parents moved house some years later I was very pleased that the bike didn't follow me to the new house. I'm not sure how bad you have to be to get an albatross hung round your neck (clicking wiki gives facts without emotional context) - but that bike was an albatross for the young C2.
If present giving is in any sense balanced then the cost of what I might (wouldn't) give you would be balanced by the cost of what you might give me - I know exactly what I want (usually nothing - I already have everything I want or need and much besides) - so ... well there you have it. If you really must give something then anything with alcohol in will be received with gratitude in proportion to the volume of pure alcohol contained.
Z. Wrote:My long departed F-I-L always gave my kids used stuff, even things he purloined from the curb, toys that people were tossing out. My kids didn't know any different.- Yes, absolutely - a present you can put back outside the house (without guilt) to be collected by anyone who wants it is a good present.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - Secular Sanity - Dec 19, 2018
We had a family member that was infamous for her gifts. She passed away last year. She was pretty wealthy. She was an author of self-help bullshit. One year she gave my mother in-law a used plastic table cloth covered in food. My most memorable gift was three balls with a book, "Any Idiot Can Juggle'. Fuckin’ Bitch!
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - Syne - Dec 19, 2018
Wow, you'd think people never heard about not looking a gift horse in the mouth. Sounds like some people could save themselves a lot of ill-will by just foregoing gifting altogether.
Santa is basically the only model for objective morality secular children have left. He basically models the omniscience and justice of god. Or if you prefer, a template for objective self-awareness and sense of karma. As such, I would expect secular children to be devastated by the truth, as they don't already have religion as another such model.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - confused2 - Dec 20, 2018
Syne Wrote:Wow, you'd think people never heard about not looking a gift horse in the mouth. Sounds like some people could save themselves a lot of ill-will by just foregoing gifting altogether.Absolutely. As it happens, along with many cringeworthy and expensive presents Mrs C2 gave my niece 3 juggling balls (without the book). Ten years later she (the niece) can juggle like a pro - one hell of a party trick when compared to (say) being able to fart 3 blind mice.
Syne Wrote:Santa is basically the only model for objective morality secular children have left. He basically models the omniscience and justice of god. Or if you prefer, a template for objective self-awareness and sense of karma. As such, I would expect secular children to be devastated by the truth, as they don't already have religion as another such model.
We have a cultural disconnect here. I have to sleep now - I will try to come back to it.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - Secular Sanity - Dec 20, 2018
(Dec 20, 2018 02:28 AM)confused2 Wrote: As it happens, along with many cringeworthy and expensive presents Mrs C2 gave my niece 3 juggling balls (without the book). Ten years later she (the niece) can juggle like a pro - one hell of a party trick when compared to (say) being able to fart 3 blind mice.
That’s funny, C2, but I was thirty with two little ones. I was juggling. Three blind mice, eh? We may have a gender disconnect here but I’ll work on it.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - Syne - Dec 20, 2018
(Dec 20, 2018 04:13 AM)Secular Sanity Wrote: Three blind mice, eh? We may have a gender disconnect here but I’ll work on it.
Oh, that one must be cultural too, as I've never known any guy trying to fart tunes. Belch maybe, and not guys I ever associated with, but never fart.
RE: “Santa survey” shows children stop believing in Father Christmas at age eight - confused2 - Dec 20, 2018
Probably best not to do all the notes at the same time.