![]() |
|
The new astrology: Economics + Lie detector is junk science + Phantom flying machines - Printable Version +- Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum (https://www.scivillage.com) +-- Forum: Science (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-61.html) +--- Forum: Junk Science (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-88.html) +--- Thread: The new astrology: Economics + Lie detector is junk science + Phantom flying machines (/thread-2225.html) |
The new astrology: Economics + Lie detector is junk science + Phantom flying machines - C C - Apr 5, 2016 The new astrology: Economics https://aeon.co/essays/how-economists-rode-maths-to-become-our-era-s-astrologers EXCERPT: By fetishising mathematical models, economists turned economics into a highly paid pseudoscience... The ‘Lie Detector’ Test Revisted: A Great Example of Junk Science http://www.csicop.org/si/show/the_lie_detector_test_revisted_a_great_example_of_junk_science EXCERPT: . . . Much of the American public seems to be convinced that the “lie detector” is valid, as indicated by its ubiquitous use in “whodunit” literature and on television crime, psychology, talk, and news shows. After all, faced with such an avalanche of widespread approbation, who could doubt the validity of such a test? Supporting this illusion is the fact that federal, state, and local police departments and law enforcement agencies across the United States are generally avid proponents of this method. But let’s take a closer look at this subject. Questions about the accuracy of this test should be amenable to modern scientific methods. Interestingly, this challenge is strikingly similar to those we face regularly as medical researchers and practitioners when we evaluate various tests in the attempt to establish the presence or absence of many diseases. Through this lens, therefore, I can provide some insight on a method that is often uncritically analyzed.... Phantom Flying Machines http://daily.jstor.org/phantom-flying-machines/ EXCERPT: Is it a coincidence that UFOs look like the technology of the time in which they are reportedly seen? The first “flying saucers” were reported in 1947, at the dawn of the jet age, indeed the very year the U.S. Air Force became its own separate branch of the armed forces. As the Cold War race for space rocketed through the 1950s, the USAF came up with the category Unidentified Flying Object for reports that could not otherwise be explained. But that wasn’t the first time unexplained flying objects caught the public’s imagination. Robert E. Bartholomew calls the numerous Michigan sightings of “airships” in 1897 an episode of mass hysteria. He situates them in the context of rapid technological change, with the telephone, electricity, and those new-fangled horseless carriages stirring things up, and much discussion of flying machines. For flying machines were in the air, of metaphor if not quite the actual atmosphere yet. People were working, often in secret, on powered heavier-than-air flying machines all over the country.... RE: The new astrology: Economics + Lie detector is junk science + Phantom flying machines - elte - Apr 5, 2016 It seems a problem with a lie detector is that it couldn't be any more accurate than the testee's memory, which many people specializing in the legal field would admit is largely unreliable. |