![]() |
|
Secular materialism's reduction of quality to quantity - Printable Version +- Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum (https://www.scivillage.com) +-- Forum: Science (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-61.html) +--- Forum: Alternative Theories (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-130.html) +--- Thread: Secular materialism's reduction of quality to quantity (/thread-21910.html) |
Secular materialism's reduction of quality to quantity - Magical Realist - Nov 20, 2026 “Modern persons in general cannot conceive of any other science than that of things that can be measured, counted, and weighed, in other words material things, since it is to these alone that the quantitative point of view can be applied; the claim to reduce quality to quantity is very typical of modern science. This tendency has reached the point of supposing that there can be no science, in the real meaning of the word, except where it is possible to introduce measurement, and that there can be no scientific laws except those that express quantitative relations. [...] We will not dwell on the mistake of seeking to reduce quality to quantity, [...] we will remark only, in this connection, that even in the sensible order, a science of this kind has but little connection with reality, the greater part of which is bound to elude it.”― René Guénon, The Crisis of the Modern World “What does the money machine eat? It eats youth, spontaneity, life, beauty and above all it eats creativity. It eats quality and shits out quantity.” ― William S. Burroughs “Scientists are extremely keen on “common sense”, yet their hero Albert Einstein dismissively said, “Common sense is the collection of prejudices acquired by the age of eighteen.” Your senses and your common sense are both insufficient to the task that scientism assigns to them. They don’t tell you shit. As Bishop Berkeley pointed out, you have no experience of any objective thing called “matter”. Instead, you have a subjective experience of a subjective idea of what you label “matter”. You always encounter the idea of matter in your mind. You have no non-mental encounter with anything called matter, so where is your evidence that matter even exists? As Berkeley demonstrated, “matter” is a redundant hypothesis.” ― Thomas Stark, Extra Scientiam Nulla Salus: How Science Undermines Reason “Many scientific disciplines begin by not observing any sort of vital spark or consciousness in material events and proceed to deny that these things exist in living things, including themselves. Because consciousness does not fit into their mechanistic schemes they declare it illusory. Magicians make exactly the reverse argument. Observing consciousness in themselves and animals, they are magnanimous enough to extend it to all things to some degree—trees, amulets, planetary bodies, and all. This is a far more respectful and generous attitude than that of religions, most of whom won't even give animals a soul.” ― Peter J. Carroll, Liber Null and Psychonaut: An Introduction to Chaos Magic "If materialism is true, it seems to me that we cannot know that it is true. If my opinions are the result of the chemical processes going on in my brain, they are determined by the laws of chemistry, not those of logic."— J.B.S. Haldane “Normal is getting dressed in clothes that you buy for work and driving through traffic in a car that you are still paying for—in order to get to the job you need to pay for the clothes and the car, and the house you leave vacant all day so you can afford to live in it.”― Ellen Goodman “Their constant outward-looking, their mania for radios, cars, and a thousand other trinkets made them dream and fix their eyes upon the trash of life, made it impossible for them to learn a language which could have taught them to speak of what was in their or others' hearts. The words of their souls were the syllables of popular songs.”― Richard Wright, Black Boy “Earn, consume, and enjoy life. Offend no one; don’t get offended. Don’t take sides; don’t take a stand. Don’t interfere; don’t get affected. Just earn, consume, and enjoy life. Mature people are disgusting.” ― Abhaidev, The Gods Are Not Dead “I was lucky to live in New York when it was dangerous and edgy and cheap enough to play host to young, penniless artists. That was the era of "coffee shops" as they were defined in New York—cheap restaurants open round the clock where you could eat for less than it would cost to cook at home. That was the era of ripped jeans and dirty T-shirts, when the kind of people who are impressed by material signs of success were not the people you wanted to know.”― Edmund White, City Boy: My Life in New York in the 1960s and 70s “Whatever way we learn, we will find that it is not cogito that is important but that you are a cog. You are a cog in a machine that does not need your cognition. You must merely conform to the coordinated.” ― James Tunney, TechBondAge: Slavery of the Human Spirit Symbols and signs that refer to nothing at all.. Right off the bat? Numbers, which name the amounts and sums of other mere amounts and sums as if such can even exist. And even worse, as objective standards of quantity supposedly universally applicable to all phenomena. As if the 5 fingers on your hand and the 5 stages of grief describe in exactly the same way totally different things. Pure invariant abstractions as if existing in themselves beyond space and time and drained of all phenomenal qualities and distinctiveness, including other hegemonic modes of quantifying and measuring human subjects like mental health testing, weight, IQ, money, wealth, your credit score, age, school grading, nielsen ratings, box office returns, political elections, polls, resumes, college degrees, the stock market, quotas, red lining, market trends, lifespan extention, risk assessment, nutrition/dieting, statistics, criminal records, generational labeling, etc and etc. And how about categories, like "success" or "ethnicity" or "normalcy" or "dysfunctionality" , which nowhere turn up in our sensory experience at all? An idealized and totally abstract set in which individual subjects acquire new identity as mere instances or members of the same set. The fiction of meaning anything at all by simply classifying and reifying and pigeon-holing individual things. Which then justifies treating them all the same way--a standardization and mechanization of action as procedures and methods and techniques and algorithms. Treating people generically as all the same until eventually they become whittled down AS the same thru that very treatment. The individual subject effectively reduced to a mere type. Hence defining and quantifying and numbering and tagging as attempts to control and have power over subjects which in their very being are free and self-determinate and opened up to the possibility of becoming other than one thing. RE: Secular materialism's reduction of quality to quantity - Magical Realist - Nov 20, 2026 Here's a great elucidation from the "Closer To Truth" series of Henri Bergson's view of Time and how the modern penchant of reductive physicalism to fragment and quantify loses touch with the true nature of Time as pure changeful and qualitative Duration: https://youtu.be/efUHAMdViZE |