![]() |
|
Article No one actually knows how the Grand Canyon formed? - Printable Version +- Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum (https://www.scivillage.com) +-- Forum: Science (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-61.html) +--- Forum: Geophysics, Geology & Oceanography (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-73.html) +--- Thread: Article No one actually knows how the Grand Canyon formed? (/thread-21899.html) |
No one actually knows how the Grand Canyon formed? - C C - Nov 19, 2026 https://www.yahoo.com/news/science/articles/no-one-knows-grand-canyon-110000741.html EXCERPTS: Karl Karlstrom, a geologist with a shock of white hair and a squint that betrays a lifetime of surveying harsh desert vistas, was bedeviled by other concerns. [...] By all logic of water and gravity, the Colorado River should be somewhere else, having found a simpler path downhill that didn't involve barreling its way through this bulwark of high ground. "Why does the crazy river come south and then all of a sudden take a hard right and go across an uplift?" Karlstrom had asked when we'd first spoken about this conundrum. He grew up near the Grand Canyon and worked as a river guide before he became a geologist; now he's joined the scientific argument about this problem of the Grand Canyon—a dispute that's been ongoing for more than 150 years. A decade ago Karlstrom thought he had it solved. But new evidence has flared the debate once again, and it doesn't center on the canyon at all. As we looked out, he gestured toward the empty landscape to the east, a vast desert basin that seemed desperate to absorb any water the puffy little rain cloud might deign to release. "Bidahochi land," Karlstrom said, "is all out there." The origin of the Grand Canyon might seem easy to figure out: rivers carve canyons, and the Colorado River carved this one. But that can't be the full story. Not all rivers form canyons; you need not just water but upward movement, or uplift, of the surrounding land for the river to cut into. Hard rock and aridity help—without them, vegetation absorbs water, and soft sediment tends to crumble into gentle slopes rather than form dramatic cliffs. In that sense the story of the Grand Canyon is the story of the American West: its climate, its tectonic forces and the way the Colorado River gathered itself into a single ribbon from its headwaters in the Rocky Mountains to its terminus in the Pacific. All of this happened millions of years before humans even evolved. The first of our species to encounter the canyon would have found it largely as it exists today. [...] Some researchers think that the modern-day canyon dates back 70 million years and that the Colorado River didn't carve most of it at all. Instead, they propose, it would have been made by rivers flowing in the opposite direction back when the dinosaurs still roamed Earth. "At some later point the Colorado River opportunistically exploited this older canyon system," says Rebecca Flowers, a geochronologist at the University of Colorado Boulder whose research on the cooling of minerals in canyon rocks supports this view. Many geologists disagree. The topography of the Grand Canyon "screams young canyon," says Kelin Whipple, a geomorphologist at Arizona State University, and the mineral-cooling methods that support the older date aren't precise. We'll let this argument lie because even old-canyon proponents such as Flowers agree that the eastern part of the Grand Canyon was carved mostly in the past six million years. And that eastern part, where the river slices through the Kaibab Plateau, is the subject of today's most vociferous debates. So: Most geologists pin the beginning of the Grand Canyon's carving to about six million years ago, and the process has been ongoing ever since. [...] The researchers tracked the river's development through land and time, finding that it entered Utah between 25 million and eight million years ago, then the Bidahochi basin upstream of the Grand Canyon seven million to six million years ago, finally flowing downstream of the canyon 4.8 million years ago. The new data reveal that the river flowed through the Bidahochi, far from where it runs today, before it made it to the Grand Canyon and that it formed in a neat process from its headwaters to its terminus. Even better, the results essentially nail down the Colorado River's path right up to the moment it hit the Grand Canyon. Now instead of five million missing years of river history, researchers are lacking only about a million or two—the time in which the river was within the canyon itself. [...] Maybe it's a good sign that the differences are subtle. Maybe over 150 years' worth of symposia and dueling research papers, scientists have been carving away at their hypotheses and getting closer to a consensus on the canyon's origin. But the two competing visions also point to vastly different ancient landscapes and, ultimately, two distinct solutions to the mystery of how water made it over the barricade of the Kaibab. I left Douglass in the Bidahochi basin, where he was preparing to scout for more ancient shorelines amid the sagebrush. And when I said goodbye to Karlstrom and Crossey on the South Rim, it was to send them off to the same lonely desert on the hunt for the braids of ancient rivers... (MORE - missing details) RE: No one actually knows how the Grand Canyon formed - Magical Realist - Nov 19, 2026 Oh now you're gonna get all the young earth creationists' dicks hard! Any slightest hint that geologists might be wrong about their alleged 5000 yr old flood-washed canyon. |