Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum
"Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - Printable Version

+- Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum (https://www.scivillage.com)
+-- Forum: Culture (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-49.html)
+--- Forum: Zymology (https://www.scivillage.com/forum-56.html)
+--- Thread: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) (/thread-21141.html)

Pages: 1 2


"Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Aug 20, 2026

CRITICAL DRINKER
https://youtu.be/DBdYGCBdqhk

The anti-superhero spirit that started on Amazon Prime with The Boys now continues on HBO. And another Damon Lindelof race-baiter sporting the usual left-angelical sermons and Hollywood caricatures of people in flyover country. "So, the two lads eventually get summoned to evil redneck man's house. I know he's evil because he's a white man who lives on a ranch and immediately starts talking about wanting to protect the planet from anyone who wasn't born there." Why did the working class rebel against literary intellectuals and their supporters in the upper classes of the East and West coasts? [shrug] Only Hera's hairdresser knows for sure (surely not the negative stereotypes; it's not like marginalized population groups would get similarly upset over those)...

Lanterns - A superhero show that hates superheroes ... https://youtu.be/DBdYGCBdqhk

https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/DBdYGCBdqhk


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - Magical Realist - Aug 20, 2026

Well, it's not like rural American anti-intellectualism is some sort of snobbish made-up Hollywood trope. But the very view that this is real sort of feeds on itself, fueling even more country folk fury that they are stereotyped and depicted on film as having such views.

"Rural anti-intellectualism is a distrust of academic experts and institutional authorities rooted in place-based identity. Rather than just a lack of schooling, it reflects a psychological view of urban-centric elites as an out-group that threatens local values, traditions, and economic survival.

Core Causes

Identity and Alienation: Strong psychological attachment to a rural identity frames outside experts as urban interlopers who look down on small-town life.

Economic Neglect: The loss of local farms, banks, and industries creates resentment toward the institutional systems that allowed rural decline.

Epistemic Divides: Conflicts arise when standardized, expert-driven policies (like public health or environmental rules) clash with practical, local knowledge.

Social and Political Impacts

Populist Support: Mistrust of academic authority heavily drives populist political movements.

Science Skepticism: Communities show higher resistance to scientific consensus on topics like public health mandates and climate change.

Brain Drain: There is a consensus on platforms like Reddit that cultural friction makes it harder to retain specialized professionals like doctors and educators in rural regions."


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Aug 21, 2026

I may have to watch this opening episode just to sort out what's truly going on. There's no way Lindelof would have "space alien migrants" be Zionist invaders instead of victims (as speculated below). Would go against the whole tediously predictable moral message that the show is proposed to be propped up around.
- - - - - - - - - - - - -

NERDROTIC DAILY
https://youtu.be/l1sVsSe1who

INTRO: Nerdrotic analyzes the premiere of the new series Lanterns, critiquing its departure from established source material and tone. The discussion covers concerns regarding character portrayals, narrative structure, and the execution of specific tropes...

VIDEO EXCERPTS: And I wasn't really grabbed or drawn in by a Hal Jordan who is an alcoholic, arrogant, scruffy loser. Who has obviously changed in the last 10 years. Something broke him. Another boring, overused trope.

So Hal Jordan says at some point in the show that the crash was coordinated because they really didn't want Earth to be part of the Green Lanterns. That this is all some kind of conspiracy blah blah blah blah whatever.

But they're trying to make it like a Taylor Sheridan show, right? They have a Taylor Sheridan villain. I wouldn't be surprised because they hate Taylor Sheridan in Hollywood. They're jealous of him. [Achieved success without going up through their protocols.] I'm speculating that I wouldn't be surprised if they take a shot at Taylor Sheridan. Did you see what the county was called? It's called Sheridan County.

And and like I'm like, "Oh my [ __ ] god, they actually did it." Because I was just joking. But they really called it Sheridan County.

They encounter -- what's the ranch owner's name? Yeah. Basically, the guy from "Army of the Dead".

[...] So, he's sitting there talking to Hal about aliens, like he knows about the aliens and he's the one who bails Hal out. And then he gets in this whole conversation about colonization as colonization. Why would you use that word? Horrible.

Because it's all an immigration allegory. Everything is just an immigration allegory.

Wouldn't you use the word conquering, instead? Like a dude from middle America just throwing out the word "colonization" conversationally would just never fly...

So he's an alien himself, or this was written by Damon Lindelof. I don't know what it is, but nobody would just start talking about "colonization". [...] He said I'm not an isolationist with my head in the sand, and then he gets into colonization. It's like you're talking about alien races conquering, not colonizing.

Like that was a red flag. How that was a Tom Kingism, because nobody brings that up in conversation unless you're an academic intellectual or we have to talk about it here on YouTube or something...

Lanterns is stupid ... https://youtu.be/l1sVsSe1who

https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/l1sVsSe1who


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Aug 22, 2026

Meh. I watched the first episode. This show is almost a kind of buddy film action comedy. It's only "anti-superhero" in the sense that 1960s "Batman" was: a parody. Not the deep, cynical sadism of The Boys satire. And like the Supergirl movie, Jordan doesn't even wear his costume.

Oh, it's going to have serious elements in it -- it's not remotely that degree of Adam West Batman. And since the show seems to accept that some space aliens actually are dangerous -- after all, the Green Lanterns are a kind of interstellar police force -- the rancher guy is more ambiguous right now rather than portrayed as "evil". There may be no bleeding heart "migrant allegory" to it at all, though it's still possible.

Yeah, it's got the neo-Western thing to it, but not clear that it's mocking Sheridan. Could as much be emulating him.

How the show will deal with the main character being dead -- I have not a clue. Will John Stewart just imaginatively recall him the way Dexter does his stepfather? Or will it be a digital persona of Jordan stored in the ring? Or maybe Jordan even faked his death -- the body was created by the ring?


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - Syne - Aug 22, 2026

I assumed John Stewart was the main protagonist, with Hal Jordan just playing the mentor sending him off on his hero's journey (such as it may be).


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Aug 22, 2026

(Aug 22, 2026 05:43 AM)Syne Wrote: I assumed John Stewart was the main protagonist, with Hal Jordan just playing the mentor sending him off on his hero's journey (such as it may be).

Kyle Chandler is ranked above Aaron Pierre (Stewart) on the Lantern's cast (as well as the poster depicting them together), so he will be there the whole season. The mystery is in what form.

And at the end of this episode, it jumps ten years ahead from 2016 to 2026, when Stewart's training should have long since been completed. So that muddles things even more. The show could alternate back and forth between scenes of the present and scenes of the past.

That would sort of echo The Madison, where Kurt Russell was listed second on the cast behind Michelle Pfeiffer. He gets killed but keeps being revived throughout the season via memories.

But Lanterns revealed early on that the ring stores past versions of Hal Jordan that can appear as holograms. They surely stuck that in there for a reason, which hints that he really is dead. The #1 cast ranking and the ring's ability to even generate bogus corpses only leave a small window open that he's still alive.

The storyline could even use the simulated Jordan for the time being and then several episodes later reveal that the real Jordan is yet kicking.


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - Syne - Aug 22, 2026

Aaron Pierre has nine episodes to Chandler's eight. Yeah, between flashbacks and more of the ring-Hal, there's plenty of opportunities already... with Hal remaining "fridged."

Pierre seems too wooden to carry the show.


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Aug 23, 2026

Despite the sort of "Lethal Weapon" buddy appearance in the poster and the True Detective duos, nobody's letting go of the conviction that there's cryptic messaging in the series and that they're ultimately going to turn Hal Jordan into a monster. Wink
- - - - - - - - - -

DRINKER'S CHASERS
https://youtu.be/p20uWfk5Zyk

VIDEO EXCERPTS: It is a superhero show made by people who aren't interested in superheroes for people who don't like superheroes. ... They're not putting on the costumes. They clearly have disdain for the costumes.

Hal Jordan, so far based on what we've seen, is dead. There are a lot of people saying there are 14 species in the DC universe that could possibly shapeshift. The fact that his ring is missing is not evidence because the ring would take off if he died and choose another replacement.

[...] I watched Damon Lindelof's Watchmen (2019) and that was enough for me to know where this guy comes from. In the script some of his personal beliefs crept in. And in your video he had a hard time grappling with making this guy a hero. He doesn't like him. ... Damon Lindelof came out and acknowledged it and said, "Everybody's been waiting for Hal Jordan, and we're going to kill him and make him an idiot."

That's shocking, isn't it? You know, and it's getting so old. ... The Lindelof interview, where he was sounding very similar to Christopher Nolan. Stating that the problem nowadays is that you can't pitch anything hopeful or good because the audience will immediately reject it. Because when they walk outside everything is getting worse.

So it seems that Hollywood is now projecting their own attitude into stories. So because they can't myopically see anything except horror all the time, they have to put that into their work. They can't even present like escapism at this point because they think it's important that you need to be told everything [preached at].

[...] As you mentioned, Gary, I have not forgotten Watchmen (2019). Most other people probably have, but I remember it. And I remember what a [__] calamity that show was, what a joke it was to the source material. And it was Damon Lindelof and his insane race-baiting [__] fetish for politics that was entirely driven by him. After that I honestly thought he would never work in Hollywood again. That show was such a disaster. They never did a season two.

[...] And let's keep in mind that he got fired by Kathleen Kennedy. So you have to be a pretty hardcore chicken molester to be fired by Kathleen Kennedy. Jesus...


JDA Talks Comics
https://youtu.be/eexIqW50PlI

VIDEO EXCEPTS: Lanterns is kind of a success, which is sort of surprising, but maybe not.

[...] Their promotional strategy is the direct opposite of what we saw with Supergirl earlier this summer. Where people just avoided the box office completely. Because the studio foolishly sent Milly Alcock out there to arrogantly rant about how she didn't want Christian dads to watch the film and other angry, crazy things directed at the potential audience.

And that just like spiraled things to a point where like people were like, "Okay, I'm not going to take my family to go see this film."

Lanterns, on the other hand, really didn't have that much negative press. David Lindelof made a joke about the color green, which was obnoxious, saying that he didn't like that. Grant Morrison, a Green Lantern writer from the comics, came right out and said that was a dumb statement. And Lindelof actually apologized for it. And that was pretty much the end of the bad press cycle for them.

Everything else has just been mostly staying on target and just being much more disciplined about things than they usually are. And I think that matters a big deal for it.

[...] I covered the first episode, and I did a review of it. I was not kind to it. What I found frustrating is that they could have done something pretty decent with this setup. But instead they just window-dressed all their weird little political fetishes in a subtle way to trick audiences more than anything else.

[...] From what my insider told me, Jordan does not die all the way. He turns into the villain Parallax through this. So, of course the Black character is then obligated to have to slay the white menace or tyrant who was once his mentor. That is the message that they're trying to present here.

[...] They obviously had the rancher who seems to be okay with getting cucked by his wife. And they tried to make him look like JD Vance. If you look at the stills, it's pretty obvious...

So you've got a lot of woke elements to it. They're just well buried into the script. They have finally learned not to highlight their dripping ideological venom directly in the faces of the audience. And that's exactly why most audiences can accept that kind of a thing. If it's subtly done like that.

[...] The critics are like, "This is the best thing ever." Loving all the wokeness that they put into it. Love all the like millennial slop they put into it. The production values look pretty good, and there is some compelling storyline behind it, even though this episode had its problems and its flaws, which are pretty obvious if these people were not shilling. But it is what it is. The political values make it easy for them to shill for it...


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Aug 26, 2026

So the second episode apparently ignored the whole dead Jordan in 2026 cliffhanger and went totally back to the unfolding events of 2016.

Officially got into some white guilt and privilege lecturing slash ranting (the YouTubers did predict that political direction correctly).

Also taking great strides to depict Jordan as an idiot (he forgot the lantern that recharges his ring). Which Lindelof supposedly boasted about some time ago in an interview when referring to how much he hated the character. Complaints about not much of anything happening in this episode, too.

John Stewart accidentally creates a green bird with the ring that stays alive (Jordan's corpse in 2026 wasn't green, barring the snow and ice masking that).

Nerdrotic Daily ... https://youtu.be/uyGjPiGAGtA

https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/uyGjPiGAGtA


RE: "Lanterns": No, the hellfire & brimstone preaching hasn't stopped (TV brewing) - C C - Sep 6, 2026

UPDATE (sort of)

In addition to the below, insiders are still claiming that Lanterns is also loosely based on the much later Emerald Twilight story arc. Where Hal Jordan gradually becomes the super-villain Parallax and eventually dies. So that's the "destruction of the whole legacy of Hal Jordan" angle that the fans are moaning about. (Burn and raze that Wyatt Debble down to the ground like Carthage and pour salt on the earth to boot!) John Stewart would be replacing Kyle Rayner's role in that narrative.

So here's the thing: John Stewart was originally introduced back in 1972 as a politically militant Black character. Which was endemic to that New Left, volatile civil rights era, and thereby a personal attribute that was justifiable. In later decades Stewart's militancy was dropped due to it becoming an anachronism. That "angry young Black man" stereotype that conforms to everlasting grievance culture.

Lanterns, however, has arguably revived that vintage "you a whitey" political attitude for its setting of 2016 (which was a spike period for critical race theory) and combining elements of that 60s-70s historic activism with today's neo-Marxist buzzwords like "privilege". Ergo, the now ensuing ruckus over and accusations about yet again hijacking a classic supe comic book for an ideological agenda and para-religious sermonizing.

And Nicholson backs up that the TV show is indeed also a promotional piece for the Democratic Party:

EXCERPT: [...] In the same article, J. Alphonse Nicholson, who plays the hero's father, John Stewart Sr., in flashbacks, discussed the show’s portrayal of racial dynamics. [...] "Could you imagine where we would be right now if Kamala got up in there, dog? Could you imagine how we would’ve been? It’d be a lot different, right? So we’re experiencing the consequences of not trusting a Black woman," Nicholson said in the clip, connecting the show’s themes of heroism to Harris’ 2024 candidacy.

SOURCES

John Stewart (in comic book history)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stewart_(character)

Writer Vanessa Baden Kelly explains "Lanterns"
https://www.thewrap.com/creative-content/tv-shows/lanterns-episode-3-john-stewart-origin-changes-explained/

New HBO superhero show faces 'woke' criticism for reframing classic hero lore around racial privilege
https://www.foxnews.com/media/hbo-superhero-show-faces-woke-criticism-reframing-classic-hero-lore-racial-privilege

Who needs Green Lantern fans? This is a political allegory, not entertainment ... https://youtu.be/NoSbcAUJbgo

https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/NoSbcAUJbgo