Points of contradiction:
1. God is not all-powerful because He has to obey the laws of Physics as He is subject to reality whenever He pops into existence.
2. God does not cause natural disasters.
3. God is loving, but due to His limitations, He cannot control or observe everything.
4. God did not create the universe because He is non-physical, it is self-creating.
This is human fallibility and has no bearing on a God. Even a personal one.
To deny the evidence for the existence of universal consciousness is to deny metaphysics in all its splendor. God is 100% real. But psychology attempts to undermine His existence by relegating it to human psychological mechanisms. This is a limited view. This simplistic presentation of yours does little to sway my certainty in the existence of God as I possess rock solid evidence. If that was your intent it has failed.