Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum

Devastating expose of Israel's targeted mass killings of Gazan citizens directed by two Israelis:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GY79iZahszU

Antisemites congratulating each other for outstanding antisemitic hatred and propaganda.

Two screens, one choice: The lie of ‘NAZA’ and the truth of ‘Fauda’

I was there. And in a sense, I have been inside both films.

The first is “NAZA,” an Israeli movie that won the Special Jury Prize at the Venice Film Festival and received an astonishing 25-minute standing ovation on Saturday.

Do not be deceived by the applause.

The creators are themselves Jews and Israelis. That creates a double deception: The film can be presented to international audiences not merely as an accusation against Israel, but as an accusation seemingly validated from within Israeli society itself.

Yet they employ against the Jews one of the oldest weapons in the arsenal of antisemitism: a blood libel.
I investigated the Israel Defense Forces’ war on the ground, including the deaths of civilians that “NAZA” depicts as the consequence of a deliberate policy of cruelty and extermination.

The truth is the opposite.

Then there is the second screen: Netflix, where millions of viewers around the world are watching the TV series “Fauda.” It is a magnificent series, and in its latest season, it confronts an international audience with something many people have never truly understood: the horror of Oct. 7, 2023.

In the aftermath of the Hamas massacre, I visited the burned-out kibbutzim. I walked through the homes of murdered young people and saw blood in kindergartens. I saw the dead piled up. I listened to parents and children and heard testimony about rape and other atrocities.

These are the two screens now before us: the lie and the truth.
...
Indeed, the more I have investigated Israel’s conduct of this war, the more convinced I have become of something extraordinary: Never in the history of warfare has an army done so much to try to protect the civilian population of its enemy. Never.
...

"As of August 2026, at least 74,582 Palestinians have been reported killed in Gaza since the war began on October 7, 2023. Approximately 1,200 people were killed in the October 7 attacks in 2023."---Google AI

Hmm...something doesn't add up.

This isn't an eye for an eye. It's a thousand eyes for an eye.

If all of the targeted deaths were combatants and only incidental civilians who didn't heed ample warnings to evacuate (while Hamas was telling them not to), it's an outright lie to claim Israel had any policy of targeting civilians.

And yes, you keep fighting and killing the enemy until they no longer have any ability to attack your own civilians. The number of instigating hostiles killed is irrelevant. The only figure that matters is whether your own people are safe.

You know, if you're at all rational and not a vile antisemite.

The documentary NAZA does not identify the people interviewed. Directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor granted complete anonymity to the 24 Israeli military and intelligence whistleblowers featured in the film. To protect their identities from legal and military repercussions, the participants' voices and appearances were digitally altered, and many were filmed only in silhouette on rooftops at night.

So there's no guarantee that those interviewed are even who the filmmakers claim.

Quote:it's an outright lie to claim Israel had any policy of targeting civilians.

Nope..meticulously documented and testified to by IDF themselves in the making of this film. You can't justify genocide anymore under the sham accusation of antisemitism. The directors are themselves Jews.

Quote:The documentary NAZA does not identify the people interviewed. Directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor granted complete anonymity to the 24 Israeli military and intelligence whistleblowers featured in the film. To protect their identities from legal and military repercussions, the participants' voices and appearances were digitally altered, and many were filmed only in silhouette on rooftops at night.

That's standard practice for whistleblowers, particularly ones working for a government intent on punishing anyone who questions their genocidal campaign. You can't hide the truth forever. The world will know the facts now.

(Sep 16, 2026 11:55 PM)Magical Realist Wrote: [ -> ]

Quote:it's an outright lie to claim Israel had any policy of targeting civilians.

Nope..meticulously documented and testified to by IDF themselves in the making of this film. You can't justify genocide anymore under the sham accusation of antisemitism. The directors are themselves Jews.

You mean anonymous people who there's no way to verify if they were ever IDF, in Gaza, or had any knowledge of command strategy. The IDF, itself, refuted all these claims.

Being a Jew doesn't magically make you honest, politically unbiased, nor even loyal to Israel.

Quote:

Quote:The documentary NAZA does not identify the people interviewed. Directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor granted complete anonymity to the 24 Israeli military and intelligence whistleblowers featured in the film. To protect their identities from legal and military repercussions, the participants' voices and appearances were digitally altered, and many were filmed only in silhouette on rooftops at night.

That's standard practice for whistleblowers, particularly ones working for a government intent on punishing anyone who questions their genocidal campaign. You can't hide the truth forever. The world will know the facts now.

That means it's complete unverified. Might as well be rumor... facts can be verified.

But rabid antisemites will lap it right up.

Quote:Being a Jew doesn't magically make you honest, politically unbiased, nor even loyal to Israel.

It automatically rules out antisemitism as a motive for this documentary. And loyalty is a non-issue when your own govt is committing blatant war crimes and genocide.

Quote:That means it's complete unverified. Might as well be rumor... facts can be verified.

Firsthand experiences of the IDF's practices by their own soldiers is verification and confirms other independent reports of civilian carnage by Palestinians. The documentary is a powerful indictment of Israel's genocidal campaign and its use of AI technologies to intentionally target Gazan civilians.

(Yesterday 02:53 AM)Magical Realist Wrote: [ -> ]

Quote:Being a Jew doesn't magically make you honest, politically unbiased, nor even loyal to Israel.

It automatically rules out antisemitism as a motive for this documentary. And loyalty is a non-issue when your own govt is committing blatant war crimes and genocide.

You do know that Jews can be antisemitic, right? @_@

When a Jewish person expresses anti-Jewish ideas, is that antisemitism? It might sound odd, but yes. From the Middle Ages until the present day, there are plenty of examples of Jewish people perpetuating antisemitism, despite being Jews themselves. Sometimes it is what scholars call “internalized racism,” which is something that many minorities, including Jews, have experienced. Other times, Jews attempt to separate themselves from other Jews as a defense mechanism. But whatever the reason behind it, antisemitism from Jewish people is no more acceptable than antisemitism from non-Jewish people.
- https://unpacked.education/video/can-jew...tisemitic/

You know, like all the black Republicans Democrats always accuse of internalized racism.

Quote:

Quote:That means it's complete unverified. Might as well be rumor... facts can be verified.

Firsthand experiences of the IDF's practices by their own soldiers is verification and confirms other independent reports of civilian carnage by Palestinians. The documentary is a powerful indictment of Israel's genocidal campaign and its use of AI technologies to intentionally target Gazan civilians.

There's zero verification that they are IDF soldiers. You believe it because you want to.
"Other reports"? Oh, you mean from people taking the word of Hamas... again, without verification.

Just run-of-the-mill antisemitism. Literally age-old blood libel.

Quote:You do know that Jews can be antisemitic, right?

No they aren't. They are not prejudiced against Jews and don't hate themselves as Jews. They are against the policies of the current regime of their govt, which has nothing to do with being Jewish and everything to do with their treatment of Gazans since Oct. 7. It's a very clear and specific cause based on what they have uncovered in making this film. Slandering them as antisemitic only exposes your inability to refute any of their claims.

Quote:There's zero verification that they are IDF soldiers. You believe it because you want to.
"Other reports"? Oh, you mean from people taking the word of Hamas... again, without verification

No dumbass..Reports by the Gazan govt agencies, the UN, and about a hundred other organizations tracking the causalities of this massacre. I've already educated you on all this. I'm not repeating it just so you can play conspiracy theorist again.

"As of September 2026, the total death toll reported by the Gaza Health Ministry has risen to over 72,290 Palestinians killed since the conflict began on October 7, 2023.

Breakdown of the Data

Total Fatalities: More than 72,290 people have been reported killed, with over 172,000 wounded.

Civilian vs. Combatant Distinction: The Gaza Health Ministry does not officially separate civilian casualties from combatant deaths in its primary running count.

Demographics: United Nations agencies and independent health assessments note that women and children consistently make up roughly half to a majority (around 56%) of the documented violent deaths.

Independent Estimates: Scientific and public health studies published in outlets like The Lancet suggest that official Ministry numbers may undercount total mortality due to collapsed administrative and rescue infrastructure, with independent household surveys estimating higher overall violent and non-violent excess deaths."

(Yesterday 05:25 AM)Magical Realist Wrote: [ -> ]

Quote:You do know that Jews can be antisemitic, right?

No they aren't. They are not prejudiced against Jews and don't hate themselves as Jews. They are against the policies of the current regime of their govt, which has nothing to do with being Jewish and everything to do with their treatment of Gazans since Oct. 7. It's a very clear and specific cause based on what they have uncovered in making this film. Slandering them as antisemitic only exposes your inability to refute any of their claims. 

Educate yourself:

Understanding the Term Jewish antisemitism

Internalized Prejudice: Historians and sociologists note that some Jews absorb and project the negative stereotypes, slanders, or basic assumptions of external antisemites onto other Jews or Jewish culture itself.

Targeting "Other" Jews: Scholars like Bernard Wasserstein argue that these individuals are often not literally hating their own physical identity, but rather expressing hostility or shame toward "other" Jews or mainstream community norms.

Historical Context: Throughout history, some figures have adopted antisemitic rhetoric to gain favor with oppressive rulers or dominant host cultures (historically dubbed "court Jews") or to distance themselves from persecution. You can read more about the historical background on the Self-hating Jew Wikipedia Page.

Their claims are no better than rumor. IOW, there is nothing verifiable to refute.

Quote:

Quote:There's zero verification that they are IDF soldiers. You believe it because you want to.
"Other reports"? Oh, you mean from people taking the word of Hamas... again, without verification

No dumbass..Reports by the Gazan govt agencies, the UN, and about a hundred other organizations tracking the causalities of this massacre.

The Gazan Health Ministry is run by Hamas and the UN, WHO, etc. accept those figures without any skepticism or independent verification.

This article is about the institution run by Hamas. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_Health_Ministry

The United Nations continues to use casualty data supplied by the Hamas-run authorities in Gaza. Specifically, the UN relies on the Gaza Ministry of Health (MOH) as its primary counterpart for tracking fatalities.

So willfully believing terrorists.

Quote:I've already educated you on all this. I'm not repeating it just so you can play conspiracy theorist again.

"As of September 2026, the total death toll reported by the Gaza Health Ministry has risen to over 72,290 Palestinians killed since the conflict began on October 7, 2023.

You're citing Hamas terrorists.

And then you whine and cry about being called an antisemite.

9_9 Useful idiots.