Yesterday 11:40 PM
Gog and Magog: The Roots of the Legend in History and Reality
Humanity as an Intruder on the Scene: The World of Emptiness and Desolation
Thousands of years ago, humans were not the masters of the Earth as we know them today. The Earth was a majestic stage dominated by dense forests, large predatory animals that later became extinct, dangerous rivers, and towering rugged mountain ranges that acted as cosmic walls separating different peoples who had never known each other. In this world, humans were merely weak beings trying to survive, intruders in the natural scene, not its masters.
The stage was not for humans; rather, it was monsters, forests, deserts, and barren plains that dominated the scene and filled it. The later extinction of this vast animal population was the result of the expansion of this being (humans) through hunting and destroying their habitats, but initially, they lived in great dispersal and suffocating isolation. Humans were not interconnected; each tribe or small group lived as if on a separate planet. Humans traveled for months, perhaps years, finding only emptiness and desolation, with very few scattered villages. There were massive peoples living across immense and disconnected distances, making any encounter between them an incredible shock, as if we were speaking of other planets by today's standards; the Earth in their scale was so vast and further, at the edge of the vast empty world filled with darkness, desolation, and spaced-out empty areas thought to be endless land. In such a desolate emptiness, any news of another human group was enough to give birth to the legend of "Gog and Magog."
The Illusion of the Conqueror and the Drama of Invented Names
Perhaps the story began with an ambitious invader or conqueror, who went far beyond the borders of his kingdom into virgin lands, mistakenly thinking he had traversed the entire Earth and reached its "final edges," while reality shows that perhaps three-quarters of the world were never reached; as evidenced by our later discoveries of the Americas, Australia, Japan, and what about the Inuit peoples in the frozen North, Siberia, the vast lands of Russia, and the immense depth of Africa? But the legend of glorification made him a hero "who reached the sunset and sunrise," with stories added to him, linked to tales of many peoples that had grains of truth at their origin but were inflated by mythical imagination.
Even names like "Gog and Magog" and similar ones such as (Goliath and Talut, Harut and Marut) are actually names invented by narrators, not the real names of those peoples; they created them to give the story a dramatic tone similar to what a "producer" does in our contemporary series, where phonetically similar names are created to deepen the narrative impact and awe in the audience, just like (Shahryar and Scheherazade) or even in children’s cartoon stories like (Sharshoor and Farfor). But behind this linguistic "fantasy," there are geographic realities about peoples isolated by the vast Himalayas, the Indian Ocean, harsh deserts, and distances that made humans invent stories about strange nations beyond the unknown.
Accumulation of the Legend and "Patching It" Through the Ages
The legend of the "barrier" or "dam" was not born suddenly; it was the result of accumulations that began in the days of fruit gatherers and the Stone and Bronze Ages; initially, barriers were natural and psychological, arising from the fear of emptiness and the grandeur of nature. Over time, with the increase of human numbers, clashes between major peoples became more violent, leading to the emergence of the idea of "artificial barriers" as a necessity for survival.
The legend of Gog and Magog grew like geological layers; it accumulated from the days of scattered tribes to small towns and then empires, with each story built on top of the previous one. Later, the Great Wall of China was added to this memory as a concept of a physical barrier, onto which people projected thousands of years of terrifying imagination. The paradox is that even after Earth was revealed through satellites and airplanes, no trace of those peoples confined behind a wall of lead and copper was found. Here began a "new patching of the legend" as a foolish escape and insistence on naivety; when Earth shouted its geographical truth, they said: "They are underground!" ignoring logic that rejects the possibility of peoples like "locusts" living inside the Earth without sun or air, a claim not made by the original story, but merely insistence on not acknowledging that what the ancients believed was a fabrication stemming from their limited knowledge.
Invaders, Travelers, and the Expansion of the Narrative
The main driving axis of the legend began with a real event: many invaders sweeping and destroying an entire country. Survivors of this destruction recounted the details with exaggeration caused by shock. When people died due to an attack by an invading people, there were no relief measures as exist today, so the survivors perished from the aftermath of the invasion—hunger, cold, and disease.
The matter does not stop at invaders; it extends to the lost traveler or adventurer who might go astray and reach the outskirts of unknown peoples, returning to tell his people what he saw. With each "transfer" of news, the transmitter adds from his imagination and fear, and everyone who hears adds and increases until the simple truth becomes fierce monsters and countless nations.
There is also the scenario of repeated attacks, or the resistance of those who confronted the sweep, and the story is mythologized as an "exaggerated victory" against supernatural forces. The invaders were already many, but their numbers were exaggerated to justify the magnitude of the tragedy or the greatness of the resistance. When half or a third of the population died, the survivors carried the memory of the tragedy and transmitted it in a legendary color, turning the story of the invasion into an epic about the peoples of "Gog and Magog," sweeping the earth like a flood behind impenetrable barriers. Here emerged the role of "traveler narrators" who conveyed what was happening in distant lands with their imaginative additions, making listeners envision horrors beyond reality.
Geographical Isolation: Humanity’s Great Reservoir Behind the Himalayas
East Asia and beyond the Himalayan barrier were almost isolated by towering mountains, deserts, and oceans. This internal combination in that isolation produced similar features, appearing to outsiders as if the inhabitants were repeated copies. Stable communities near large rivers formed human reservoirs that amazed any visitor, making the region seem like a people that never ends, living behind natural barriers.
The proper roots of this multitude go back to the fact that these regions were lands of rivers and great settlement; in China alone, in addition to several famous large rivers, there are more than a thousand small rivers branching and penetrating the land, creating constant rain climates and earthly gardens allowing the population to survive and reproduce in huge numbers. If not for epidemics, massive massacres, and earthquakes throughout China’s history, and if policies like "one child" had not been followed, their numbers today would exceed all description and imagination.
Reality Versus Legend: The Conclusion
Today, we discover that these regions are the largest demographic weight on Earth; they include China, Japan, North Korea, South Korea, Mongolia, Taiwan, and all that immense human crowd in East Asia and beyond the Himalayan barrier. This digital and geographic reality confirms the essence of the old legend but contradicts its "mythical" elements; what the ancients considered "supernatural forces" is merely a natural human aggregation in fertile and isolated land.
The legend of Gog and Magog in its final form is the result of invasion shocks, narrators’ tales, and the continuous "patching of the legend" across generations. Imagination mixed reality with awe of nature and extended emptiness. The legend was not mere pure fantasy but a reflection of ancient humans’ fear of the unknown "other" separated by planetary-scale distances, and an explanation of their feeling of helplessness in the face of the amazing human multitude that geography shouts today, while some attempt to escape "underground" to avoid confronting the truth.
Regards.
Mohsen Ezz El-Din Al-Bakri
Humanity as an Intruder on the Scene: The World of Emptiness and Desolation
Thousands of years ago, humans were not the masters of the Earth as we know them today. The Earth was a majestic stage dominated by dense forests, large predatory animals that later became extinct, dangerous rivers, and towering rugged mountain ranges that acted as cosmic walls separating different peoples who had never known each other. In this world, humans were merely weak beings trying to survive, intruders in the natural scene, not its masters.
The stage was not for humans; rather, it was monsters, forests, deserts, and barren plains that dominated the scene and filled it. The later extinction of this vast animal population was the result of the expansion of this being (humans) through hunting and destroying their habitats, but initially, they lived in great dispersal and suffocating isolation. Humans were not interconnected; each tribe or small group lived as if on a separate planet. Humans traveled for months, perhaps years, finding only emptiness and desolation, with very few scattered villages. There were massive peoples living across immense and disconnected distances, making any encounter between them an incredible shock, as if we were speaking of other planets by today's standards; the Earth in their scale was so vast and further, at the edge of the vast empty world filled with darkness, desolation, and spaced-out empty areas thought to be endless land. In such a desolate emptiness, any news of another human group was enough to give birth to the legend of "Gog and Magog."
The Illusion of the Conqueror and the Drama of Invented Names
Perhaps the story began with an ambitious invader or conqueror, who went far beyond the borders of his kingdom into virgin lands, mistakenly thinking he had traversed the entire Earth and reached its "final edges," while reality shows that perhaps three-quarters of the world were never reached; as evidenced by our later discoveries of the Americas, Australia, Japan, and what about the Inuit peoples in the frozen North, Siberia, the vast lands of Russia, and the immense depth of Africa? But the legend of glorification made him a hero "who reached the sunset and sunrise," with stories added to him, linked to tales of many peoples that had grains of truth at their origin but were inflated by mythical imagination.
Even names like "Gog and Magog" and similar ones such as (Goliath and Talut, Harut and Marut) are actually names invented by narrators, not the real names of those peoples; they created them to give the story a dramatic tone similar to what a "producer" does in our contemporary series, where phonetically similar names are created to deepen the narrative impact and awe in the audience, just like (Shahryar and Scheherazade) or even in children’s cartoon stories like (Sharshoor and Farfor). But behind this linguistic "fantasy," there are geographic realities about peoples isolated by the vast Himalayas, the Indian Ocean, harsh deserts, and distances that made humans invent stories about strange nations beyond the unknown.
Accumulation of the Legend and "Patching It" Through the Ages
The legend of the "barrier" or "dam" was not born suddenly; it was the result of accumulations that began in the days of fruit gatherers and the Stone and Bronze Ages; initially, barriers were natural and psychological, arising from the fear of emptiness and the grandeur of nature. Over time, with the increase of human numbers, clashes between major peoples became more violent, leading to the emergence of the idea of "artificial barriers" as a necessity for survival.
The legend of Gog and Magog grew like geological layers; it accumulated from the days of scattered tribes to small towns and then empires, with each story built on top of the previous one. Later, the Great Wall of China was added to this memory as a concept of a physical barrier, onto which people projected thousands of years of terrifying imagination. The paradox is that even after Earth was revealed through satellites and airplanes, no trace of those peoples confined behind a wall of lead and copper was found. Here began a "new patching of the legend" as a foolish escape and insistence on naivety; when Earth shouted its geographical truth, they said: "They are underground!" ignoring logic that rejects the possibility of peoples like "locusts" living inside the Earth without sun or air, a claim not made by the original story, but merely insistence on not acknowledging that what the ancients believed was a fabrication stemming from their limited knowledge.
Invaders, Travelers, and the Expansion of the Narrative
The main driving axis of the legend began with a real event: many invaders sweeping and destroying an entire country. Survivors of this destruction recounted the details with exaggeration caused by shock. When people died due to an attack by an invading people, there were no relief measures as exist today, so the survivors perished from the aftermath of the invasion—hunger, cold, and disease.
The matter does not stop at invaders; it extends to the lost traveler or adventurer who might go astray and reach the outskirts of unknown peoples, returning to tell his people what he saw. With each "transfer" of news, the transmitter adds from his imagination and fear, and everyone who hears adds and increases until the simple truth becomes fierce monsters and countless nations.
There is also the scenario of repeated attacks, or the resistance of those who confronted the sweep, and the story is mythologized as an "exaggerated victory" against supernatural forces. The invaders were already many, but their numbers were exaggerated to justify the magnitude of the tragedy or the greatness of the resistance. When half or a third of the population died, the survivors carried the memory of the tragedy and transmitted it in a legendary color, turning the story of the invasion into an epic about the peoples of "Gog and Magog," sweeping the earth like a flood behind impenetrable barriers. Here emerged the role of "traveler narrators" who conveyed what was happening in distant lands with their imaginative additions, making listeners envision horrors beyond reality.
Geographical Isolation: Humanity’s Great Reservoir Behind the Himalayas
East Asia and beyond the Himalayan barrier were almost isolated by towering mountains, deserts, and oceans. This internal combination in that isolation produced similar features, appearing to outsiders as if the inhabitants were repeated copies. Stable communities near large rivers formed human reservoirs that amazed any visitor, making the region seem like a people that never ends, living behind natural barriers.
The proper roots of this multitude go back to the fact that these regions were lands of rivers and great settlement; in China alone, in addition to several famous large rivers, there are more than a thousand small rivers branching and penetrating the land, creating constant rain climates and earthly gardens allowing the population to survive and reproduce in huge numbers. If not for epidemics, massive massacres, and earthquakes throughout China’s history, and if policies like "one child" had not been followed, their numbers today would exceed all description and imagination.
Reality Versus Legend: The Conclusion
Today, we discover that these regions are the largest demographic weight on Earth; they include China, Japan, North Korea, South Korea, Mongolia, Taiwan, and all that immense human crowd in East Asia and beyond the Himalayan barrier. This digital and geographic reality confirms the essence of the old legend but contradicts its "mythical" elements; what the ancients considered "supernatural forces" is merely a natural human aggregation in fertile and isolated land.
The legend of Gog and Magog in its final form is the result of invasion shocks, narrators’ tales, and the continuous "patching of the legend" across generations. Imagination mixed reality with awe of nature and extended emptiness. The legend was not mere pure fantasy but a reflection of ancient humans’ fear of the unknown "other" separated by planetary-scale distances, and an explanation of their feeling of helplessness in the face of the amazing human multitude that geography shouts today, while some attempt to escape "underground" to avoid confronting the truth.
Regards.
Mohsen Ezz El-Din Al-Bakri