Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum

Full Version: Fish oil supplements ineffective? / Smart people tend to do their own thing
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Quote:        Smart people tend to make their own decisions because they believe they have the correct answer on their own.    
http://www.medicaldaily.com/majority-rul...-iq-345222

Quote:.      Oil in fish supplements may be in a largely unusable form.              
.    http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2...073015.php
Quote:The importance of a diet rich in fish oils - now a billion dollar food-supplement industry -- has been debated for over half a century


And the medical / nutritional debates will continue to flip-flop about it for another half-century because studies in this [broader] area of scientific investigation have become infamous for their unreliablity both pro and con regarding their examined targets.

Ourselves as "this particular person" is not the generalized human being having a generalized effect or non-effect or bad / beneficial reaction which abstract data outputs conclusions about. We are instead discrete bodies experiencing our own actual specific circumstances and empirical consequences in response to something. Joe Schmo claims that _X_ does nothing to thin his blood, while I bleed like a hemophiliac from the most minor cut if I take an excessive number of softgels / capsules a day.

There is definitely some bad fish oil out there that is contaminated with heavy metals and toxic chemicals, poorly effective due to destructive processing methods, etc. Some of it isn't even really marine-source oil at all, doesn't even contain EPA and DHA.

Sometimes the pharmaceutical industry is indirectly funding and ghost-writing research to bump off an over-the-counter rival. Sometimes it's the supplement industry employing lab workers or financially tweaking lab work to yield exaggerated claims.

Simply failing to advise test-subjects to take a supplement with food can skewer the results due to either decreased absorption and/or beneficial association with those other nutrients. Prescribing a low, ineffective dosage can help achieve negative results, too (CoEnzyme Q-10 never did anything for my mother's endurance of a heart problem till she obstinately got up to 400 milligrams a day [plus] amount after over a month's time). On the opposite side, some supplements in tests are intentionally corrupted with cheap amounts of actual medicinal agents to spike the results favorably.
(Jan 23, 2016 07:43 PM)C C Wrote: [ -> ]). On the opposite side, some supplements in tests are intentionally corrupted with cheap amounts of actual medicinal agents to spike the results favorably.

I had an acquaintance sorta friend who was taking some type of supplement and I suspected that his feeling good from it was because it was spiked with something.