Scivillage.com Casual Discussion Science Forum

Full Version: Is Earth inside a huge void? Possible solution to Hubble tension
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
https://sciencesources.eurekalert.org/ne...es/1090191

INTRO: Earth and our entire Milky Way galaxy may sit inside a mysterious giant hole which makes the cosmos expand faster here than in neighbouring regions of the universe, astronomers say.

Their theory is a potential solution to the 'Hubble tension' and could help confirm the true age of our universe, which is estimated to be around 13.8 billion years old.

The latest research – shared at the Royal Astronomical Society’s National Astronomy Meeting (NAM) in Durham – shows that sound waves from the early universe, "essentially the sound of the Big Bang", support this idea.

The Hubble constant was first proposed by Edwin Hubble in 1929 to express the rate of the universe's expansion. It can be measured by observing the distance of celestial objects and how fast they are moving away from us.

The stumbling block, however, is that extrapolating measurements of the distant, early universe to today using the standard cosmological model predicts a slower rate of expansion than measurements of the nearby, more recent universe. This is the Hubble tension.

"A potential solution to this inconsistency is that our galaxy is close to the centre of a large, local void," explained Dr Indranil Banik, of the University of Portsmouth.

"It would cause matter to be pulled by gravity towards the higher density exterior of the void, leading to the void becoming emptier with time. As the void is emptying out, the velocity of objects away from us would be larger than if the void were not there. This therefore gives the appearance of a faster local expansion rate."

He added: "The Hubble tension is largely a local phenomenon, with little evidence that the expansion rate disagrees with expectations in the standard cosmology further back in time. So a local solution like a local void is a promising way to go about solving the problem."

For the idea to stand up, Earth and our solar system would need to be near the centre of a void about a billion light-years in radius and with a density about 20 per cent below the average for the universe as a whole. Directly counting galaxies does support the theory, because the number density in our local universe is lower than in neighbouring regions.

However, the existence of such a large and deep void is controversial because it doesn't mesh particularly well with the standard model of cosmology, which suggests matter today should be more uniformly spread out on such large scales.

Despite this, new data presented by Dr Banik at NAM 2025 shows that baryon acoustic oscillations (BAOs) – the "sound of the Big Bang" – support the idea of a local void... (MORE - details, no ads)
How does the posit that the universe looks the same in every direction work if MW is heading in one direction? No change until MW gets close to leaving void?
(Jul 13, 2025 02:30 PM)Zinjanthropos Wrote: [ -> ]How does the posit that the universe looks the same in every direction work if MW is heading in one direction? No change until MW gets close to leaving void?

Arguably, they may usually be referring to the uniformity of microwave cosmic background. When getting away from that, though, there are a number of large cosmic structures that disrupt this expectation of pristine homogeneity.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Colossal cosmic structure should be too big to exist, say astronomers
https://newatlas.com/space/big-ring-colo...structure/

EXCERPT: Not only is the Big Ring bigger than those, but it’s bigger than should be possible for any structure to ever get. According to the Cosmological Principle, a fundamental part of physical cosmology, the universe should look uniform in all directions, for any observer anywhere within it. Sure, there are random variations in the distribution of stars and galaxies, but on the largest scales it all blends together into a homogenous pattern like static. The Cosmological Principle sets an upper limit of 1.2 billion light-years on the size of any structures – a limit that the Big Ring blatantly disregards. To continue the analogy, it would be nigh on impossible for the static on your TV to arrange itself into a big image of the Mona Lisa.