(Jan 15, 2023 03:10 AM)Kornee Wrote: [ -> ]Sabine justifiably takes a hiding:
https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/sa...r.1048994/
See p1 #6 post there, and following.
(Jan 16, 2023 01:51 PM)confused2 Wrote: [ -> ]Time dilation and acceleration..
It does seem to be a rather elementary misunderstanding/mistake for a professional physicist.
It also concerns one of her stand-alone videos unconnected with the "science news" series posted in this thread. Which is to say, if there's a need for a thread devoted specifically to trashing Hossenfelder or addressing content outside the vids of this topic, then we should probably create it elsewhere. Rather than allow a developing but unplanned process to hijack this one for such purposes (these things can incrementally emerge without anyone being motivated beforehand toward such, or intending _X_).
We have it from a couple of the "esoteric cult gurus" at PhysicsForums themselves that apparently any physicist (notable ones included) who mediates to the public ("pop-sci") is probably going to make potential errors, or generate misunderstandings just via the imprecision of ordinary language.
"Ugh. This is why I don't watch popsci about anything I know anything about. I always end up wanting to write ten page essays correcting it."
- - - - - -
"[...] This is why such videos are not suitable material for discussion of GR on here. You are attempting to understand physics by getting the right words in the correct order. Physics is only unambiguous when it gives a precise mathematical model and quantitative answers to specific questions."[1]
If they don't want members posting videos like that, then don't invite her to an interview and heap praise.
Interview with Theoretical Physicist: Sabine Hossenfelder
https://www.physicsforums.com/insights/i...senfelder/
We are pleased to introduce Sabine Hossenfelder. Sabine is a theoretical physicist from the Frankfurt Institute for Advanced Studies. Sabine also authors a very popular physics blog called backreaction.
Did they even recently twitter about that 2017 interview again, or is the "Jan 9, 2023" of this tweet just my misperception?
https://twitter.com/physicsforums/status...5057490944
I mean, the administrative clergy and/or its circle of groupies over there should strive for coherence about their views: Do they gather in clusters for pissing contests on popular science or not?
- - - footnote - - -
[1] Sounds like that common sophomoric clique which laughs at the technical nomenclature of other professions that they're unfamiliar with, but then somehow believe a public in the same fix would magically apprehend the abstractions they scribble as anything other than gibberish or symbol-salad (and accordingly switch channels on). Or a category of hecklers who are just too scared of making mistakes themselves ("
OMG, I can't have a pop-sci tag pinned to me!") to ever be mediators between science and the public.
typical response: "Oh, but we're grooming proper physics students in our online workshop."
And who originally lured wide-eyed kids and tweens in the direction of science with tidbits of fascination, accumulatively placing them at your doorstep? Science communicators (
Prometheus) willing to risk wrath on high from the Abstruse Priesthood.